Can I be sued if someone borrows my car and causes an accident?

robert1960 CA 🛠️ Specialist 👁 129 ⚑ Report Car Law

My coworker asked to borrow my car last week to pick up some furniture. While he was driving, he got into a fender bender with another vehicle. Now the other driver's insurance is contacting me directly about damages. Am I legally responsible for what happened while someone else was behind the wheel?

2 answers

★ Best answer

In most places, the car owner is held liable when someone borrows their vehicle and causes an accident - this is called "negligent entrustment" or falls under your insurance policy's coverage. Your auto insurance typically follows the car rather than the driver, so the other party's insurance will likely pursue a claim through your policy first. You should contact your own insurance company immediately before communicating further with the other driver's insurer, as they'll handle the claim and protect your interests. Whether you personally get sued depends on the damages and your state's laws, but having your insurer involved is crucial either way.

did you give your coworker permission to drive, or did he take it without asking? that matters more than you'd think, but either way yeah - you're almost certainly on the hook here.

your insurance is the first line of defense because you own the vehicle. when someone borrows your car with your permission and causes an accident, your policy typically covers it (that's called "permissive use"), even though you weren't driving. the other driver's insurance will go after your insurance first, and your rates will likely jump. if the damages exceed your coverage limits, things get messier and they could potentially come after you personally, depending on your state.

the main thing you should do right now is contact your own insurance company directly before paying anything or signing anything the other driver's insurance sends you. don't let them control the narrative - your insurer has lawyers for this. also find out exactly what your policy limits are, because if the damages are huge and you're under-insured, that's a problem. going forward, think twice about lending your car, especially to someone you work with. learned that one the hard way with a friend who borrowed my truck once.

robert1960 asker Yes, I gave permission. Thanks for the breakdown - calling my insurer today.

Your answer

Log into answer.