5 answers

★ Best answer

I wouldn't have accepted that either and would've disputed the bill. The others are right that cosmetic repairs don't belong in the operating costs - but it depends on whether your lease says otherwise. Some landlords try to slip that stuff in and then claim it's a "common area" or something like that. Check your contract and if there's nothing in there saying you have to pay for that kind of thing, I'd file a complaint and ask what legal basis they're using to charge you for it.

No, he can't do that. Cosmetic repairs like wallpapering and painting are maintenance costs that the landlord has to cover himself - they definitely don't belong in the operating costs and can't be passed on to tenants. You should object to this and dispute the billing, especially if these repairs were done before you moved in. If you're unsure, a tenant association can help you out or you can consult a lawyer.

That's not legally valid. Cosmetic repairs like wallpaper and paint are maintenance and are the landlord's responsibility - not part of the common charges for all tenants. If the work was done before you moved in, it has nothing to do with you anyway.

I had a similar case myself: the landlord wanted to spread the cost of hallway repainting across all tenants, I objected and the charges were reversed. Just write to your landlord in writing that this doesn't belong in common charges and demand a corrected statement.

Cosmetic repairs are actually the landlord's responsibility and can't simply be added to the operating costs - that's legally clear-cut. But here's the thing: check your lease to see if there's a clause that puts cosmetic repairs on you. Some contracts have that, and then the landlord could argue you should've paid - but not through operating costs, rather as a separate claim against you personally.

The annoying part is that he tried to pass it on to all tenants anyway. That's not allowed. If this really happened before you moved in, the landlord should've factored it into the rent anyway - that's part of maintenance. If it happened after you moved in and your contract says nothing about cosmetic repairs, he covers the costs entirely. I'd push back on it and dispute the bill. Send your landlord a quick email saying cosmetic repairs don't belong in operating costs and demand a corrected invoice - if needed, your tenant association can help too.

Check your lease agreement - it normally spells out what can and can't be included in the operating costs. Wallpapering and painting are classic cosmetic repairs that the landlord has to cover themselves, not the tenants. The others are right that this isn't legal. If he's charged you for it anyway, I'd reject it in writing and ask what basis he's using to do that.

Your answer

Log into answer.