Do you guys know when you last changed the rubber seal? That's the key, not how many years it's been sitting in your house! I have one that's pushing twenty-something years old and it works beautifully because I change the seal every two years and check that the lid closes perfectly, with no deformations. If your pressure cooker closes well, the seal is in good condition, and there are no dents on the rim, your sister is exaggerating a bit with the whole expiration date thing. But here's what you do need to take seriously: those seals age and lose elasticity even if it doesn't look like it, so if you can't remember the last time you gave it a proper inspection, better to spend five euros on a new one and sleep easy.