Is a savings plan with ETFs worth it for beginners?

WA wanderer_vanessa DE 🔍 Enthusiast 👁 103 ⚑ Report Investing

I'm 28 and I finally want to start doing something for retirement. My boss advised me to save with ETFs, but I have zero experience with stocks and I don't know anything about them. Is this really something for people like me, or should I stick with traditional saving?

4 answers

★ Best answer

Your boss has something for you, but honestly "zero experience" isn't really a problem when it comes to saving with ETFs. That's actually the whole point: you don't need to understand how individual stocks work. With a savings plan, you simply buy shares regularly (monthly, weekly, whatever) from a big pool that contains hundreds or thousands of companies. That's way less stressful than picking individual stocks, and historically it's worked really well over longer periods.

Saving in a regular savings account honestly doesn't do much for you these days - interest rates are still low and inflation just eats away at your money. With ETFs, your money is at least participating in market growth. At 28, you also have time to ride out short-term fluctuations, which is a big advantage. You could start with a cheap all-world ETF, set up the savings plan, and then just forget about it.

The only thing you should pay attention to: do a quick check on which bank or broker has low fees (some charge nothing for savings plans). And only save money you really don't need, otherwise you won't sleep well. But you can drop the fear of stocks when it comes to ETFs as a long-term savings plan.

ETFs are actually ideal for beginners because you don't have to analyze individual stocks - an ETF is basically a basket with hundreds or thousands of stocks in it. At 28, you still have decades until retirement, and that's a huge advantage. Fluctuations in the meantime are less relevant because you have a long time to make up for any losses.

The most common mistake I see with beginners: they start super motivated, throw in €500, then a week later see the price has dropped, and panic. Then they stop it or sell the whole thing. That's the surest way to lose money. If you set up a savings plan - say €100 or €200 a month - you don't have to worry about prices every single day. It runs automatically and you can focus on your life.

Quick question though: how regularly could you actually save? And do you have any debts or emergency savings you should build up first? A regular savings account barely gets you any returns these days, your boss is right about that. But if you need those €5,000 you've saved for the new kitchen soon, then that doesn't belong in an ETF savings plan.

wanderer_vanessa asker I could save 150-200€ a month. I don't have any debts, but I haven't built up an emergency fund yet - I still need to cover 3 months of living expenses first.

The argument about "zero experience" is actually misleading - ETF savings plans are literally designed so you don't have to mess around with individual stocks. The bigger risk that others are overlooking: a lot of beginners panic at the first market crash and sell their position at a loss instead of just keeping up with their savings. If market fluctuations would stress you out psychologically, even the best ETF won't help you - in that case, honestly, traditional savings might just be the better choice for you personally.

With regular savings, you're losing real purchasing power because interest doesn't keep up with inflation - that's actually the risk you'd be taking on. An ETF savings plan is beginner-friendly because you just pay in a fixed amount each month and don't have to worry about the rest of the selection. The only thing that matters is whether you need the money before you retire in 20+ years - for retirement planning it's perfect.

Your answer

Log into answer.