Lime plaster vs. lime-cement plaster - which is better for indoor climate?

I'm renovating my 1978 house right now and trying to figure out what to use for plastering the interior walls. The tradesman recommended lime-cement plaster to me, but my neighbor says pure lime plaster would be better for moisture regulation. What are the actual differences, and does it really make a noticeable difference when it comes to mold and room climate?

11 answers

★ Best answer

Lime-cement plaster has significantly less water vapor diffusion capacity than pure lime plaster, but that's exactly why it's often the better choice for damp old buildings - the lime in the cement plaster still acts as a regulator, while the cement component forms a protective barrier layer that prevents moisture from the masonry from being drawn inward. If you haven't clarified beforehand whether your walls were fitted with any barrier layers back in 1978 or whether they actively absorb moisture, honestly I'd go with what the tradesman says - he sees it on site and won't have to deal with mold later. A practical tip: If you do decide to go with pure lime plaster, do a simple moisture reading at several spots beforehand - it doesn't cost much and gives you peace of mind.

It's not quite that straightforward - it's not like one is fundamentally better than the other. It depends on your house and the situation. Pure lime plaster actually has higher water vapor diffusion capacity and can absorb and release moisture better, which is more helpful for room climate and against mold. Lime-cement plaster is more stable and more wear-resistant, but takes longer to dry and is less breathable - your tradesman is probably thinking about durability and load-bearing capacity.

How about your situation though: do you tend to have moisture problems or have the walls been stable so far? With older houses like yours from 1978, lime plaster is often the better choice if the outer walls weren't newly insulated and are still working with more moisture - I'd lean toward what your neighbor said in that case.

jan_fischer asker Thanks for the detailed answer! No moisture problems visible so far - but I'll check that more carefully before I make a decision.

I wouldn't just decide on one option without first checking how your house actually "behaves" - with a 1978 build you need to know whether the walls tend to be drier or more damp. Your neighbor's right that pure lime plaster can absorb and release significantly more moisture, but here's the trick: if you go with lime-cement plaster (which your tradesman probably recommends because it's more durable), you can get the best of both worlds by using a pure lime product for the top coat or painting - so lime paint or thin lime plaster as a finish. That way you get the moisture regulation without sacrificing stability.

The real difference in room climate is honestly smaller than a lot of people think - what matters more is that whatever goes on there is breathable and not some plastic film like emulsion paint. With a house this age, your windows, ventilation, and possibly damp old walls play a bigger role in mold than the plaster does anyway.

I had this exact same dilemma with my own renovation and ended up going with lime plaster - and honestly, it makes a real difference. The reason is less mystical than you'd think: lime plaster binds moisture much better and releases it again, whereas lime-cement plaster just becomes denser because of the cement content. You notice that especially in older houses like yours, where the walls tend to be damper anyway. My indoor climate became noticeably less "musty," and I used to get those small mold spots in the corners all the time.

But here's the practical trick someone showed me later: no matter which one you go with - look at the wall itself first. If your exterior walls get wet (from splash water or because the drainage is inadequate), even the best lime plaster won't help. Then you have to fix the moisture source first, otherwise no plaster will regulate that away. That's really the crucial point that a lot of people miss. Lime-cement plaster is often recommended too because it's more durable and doesn't crack as easily - and that's true - but for the indoor climate in an older house, pure lime plaster is really the better choice if the moisture is coming from inside and not seeping in from outside.

Neither one is the universal solution - it really depends on whether your walls still need to shed moisture or not. The thing is: lime plaster alone needs a stable, dry base. With a 1978 house that might still have damp masonry, that can be problematic because it'll absorb too much moisture itself and start flaking off. Lime-cement plaster is more robust against sustained dampness and lasts longer, but it regulates moisture less effectively. Have you checked whether your walls are insulated from the outside, or if there's still moisture "working" in there?

jan_fischer asker No, there's no insulation on the outside yet. The walls are partly damp, especially on the ground floor.

For a 1978 building, honestly I'd check damp-proofing first before deciding on plaster - if moisture is still coming in from outside, even the best lime plaster won't help. But if the walls are already dry, pure lime plaster makes noticeably more difference to room climate than lime-cement plaster because it balances air humidity better and gives mold fewer chances.

Have you had a moisture test done to check whether your walls are still actively releasing moisture or if they're already relatively dry? With my renovation a couple of years ago, that was exactly the deciding factor - I'd initially planned for lime-cement plaster, but the moisture measurement showed that the walls still needed to get rid of water. In that case, lime-cement plaster would have been counterproductive because it's denser and tends to push moisture inward. With pure lime plaster, everything dried out properly, and since then I've had fewer issues with condensation in winter.

The other answers are right that there's no simple universal answer, but here's the practical point: if your '78 building still has damp walls, lime plaster is better for your indoor climate. If the walls are already stably dry, lime-cement plaster does its job just fine - it's just a bit more robust and longer-lasting, but less breathable. Best thing is to get a moisture measurement done (doesn't cost much), then you'll know what you're dealing with.

jan_fischer asker Have you already had a moisture measurement done, or how would you estimate the moisture condition of your walls?

Whether your walls are actually dry from the outside, or if there are still moisture problems - that's the crucial point I felt was missing from the other answers: If your '78 house is still actively pulling water inward (leaky exterior walls, missing drainage, splash water), then even the best lime plaster won't help you - mold will come anyway. Pure lime plaster really is better for moisture regulation and room climate, BUT only if the walls are first remediated and no longer absorbing water from outside. The lime-cement plaster the tradesman suggested would be a compromise if you're uncertain - it's more forgiving in case there's still residual moisture. My tip: Have someone check the walls with a wood moisture meter first, or get a professional assessment.

The key question is whether your walls still need to actively release moisture to the outside, or if they're already dry. With a house from the seventies, that's the crucial point - a lot of old walls still have residual moisture in the masonry that needs to get out. Here I'd honestly say: lime plaster is the better choice because it's significantly more vapor-permeable and actively supports this process. Lime-cement plaster has a higher cement content, which reduces diffusion capability and can actually push moisture inward if things don't go perfectly.

The practical difference in room climate is actually noticeable, but it's not magic. Pure lime plaster buffers humidity spikes - when you shower and the walls get damp, the plaster absorbs the water and releases it again later. That does way more against mold than a dense plaster. That said, lime plaster needs proper application and shouldn't be applied directly to extremely damp masonry, or it won't work right.

My tip: get a measurement done first to see how damp your masonry actually is. A building surveyor can tell you that quickly. If the readings are still elevated, you might need a drying phase first or a special remedial plaster before you go with pure lime plaster. Then you'll actually get the better room climate sorted.

I'd recommend first checking how much moisture is actually in your walls. That's really the crucial point. If your walls are actively releasing moisture inward (which is often the case with older houses that don't have a moisture barrier), then pure lime plaster is actually the better choice - it lets water vapor through and absorbs moisture without negatively affecting your indoor climate. Lime-cement plaster is denser and can cause moisture to be pushed outward in damp walls or get backed up at the interface.

That said - and this is important - pure lime plaster only works well if the foundation is right. The walls need to be properly remediated first, meaning: remove any existing moisture barriers if present, fight rising damp, and then you can work with lime plaster. It'll then actually have a noticeable effect on your indoor climate because it buffers moisture and fewer mold problems develop. If your tradesman recommended lime-cement plaster without thoroughly analyzing the moisture situation, I'd ask some critical questions about that.

When you're renovating an older house, it's really a balancing act because both options have their merits - it just depends on what your walls need. The difference comes down to vapor diffusion: lime plaster absorbs moisture and releases it again, while lime-cement plaster is denser and doesn't "breathe" as much. At first that sounds like a clear advantage for lime, but here's the catch: if your walls are still moisture-laden (which can definitely be the case with a '78 build), you need a proper vapor barrier first or at least a sanitation plaster base layer, otherwise you're just pulling the moisture into the lime plaster and you'll end up with problems anyway.

Here's a practical tip I don't hear often: before plastering, run a simple moisture test on an inconspicuous spot - borrow a resin or carbide meter, costs almost nothing. That way you can see if the wall still has over 20% moisture. If it does, I'd go with lime-cement plaster or at least apply a sanitation plaster layer (special formula with pore formers). If the wall is already dry, you really get an advantage with pure lime plaster when it comes to room climate - it regulates noticeably better. With mold, the plaster itself isn't usually the problem but ventilation and regularly monitoring how moisture develops. The tradesperson usually recommends lime-cement plaster because they want to play it safe, but if your walls are ready for it, pure lime plaster is definitely worth it.

Your answer

Log into answer.