You're right to be skeptical here. When you dig into how these rankings actually work, they often weight things like "did the company respond to our questionnaire" or "do they have a published code of conduct" pretty heavily - stuff that's relatively cheap and easy to fake. Shein could absolutely nail those boxes while conditions on the ground stay problematic. It's the difference between looking ethical and being ethical.
The other thing that matters is which Australian retailers they're comparing against. If you're measuring against some smaller or less-known brands that have zero transparency infrastructure, then yeah, a massive company like Shein that at least has *some* public-facing policies might technically score higher. But that's kind of a low bar. It doesn't mean shopping there is suddenly fine - it just means you're comparing a giant's polished PR against someone else's lack of visibility. The real metric that matters to most people - whether workers are treated fairly and paid decently - is way harder to measure and way more likely to be hidden.