I lent my cousin $3,000 about two years ago with a handwritten agreement about repayment, and now he's ghosting me and won't pay it back. Should I pursue this in small claims court, and would that agreement even hold up?
I've been through this kind of mess before and it sucks! Small claims court can work, but here's the thing - even if you win, you still have to actually collect the money, and that's where it gets frustrating. A handwritten agreement helps your case, but the real issue is whether your cousin even has money to pay or if he's just avoiding you because he can't or won't. Before court, honestly try one more serious conversation or send him a final written demand - sometimes that wake-up call works. If it doesn't and you do file, you'll likely win on the agreement alone, but then you're stuck chasing him down for payment, which can be even harder than proving he owes you!
A handwritten agreement is generally enforceable in small claims court as long as it shows the loan amount, terms, and both signatures - judges see these all the time and they hold up. You'd want to gather whatever documentation you have (the agreement itself, texts or emails referencing the loan, any partial payments), show up with copies, and present your case; small claims is specifically designed for situations like this where the amount doesn't justify a lawyer, though rules vary by location so check your local court's website first.
Before you file, try sending him a formal demand letter (even just an email counts) stating the amount, the date of the loan, and a deadline to pay - sometimes that wake-up call is enough to get someone moving. If he still ignores it, small claims court will likely accept your handwritten agreement, but the tricky part nobody mentions enough is that winning a judgment doesn't mean the money automatically appears in your account. You'll need to figure out if he has assets or income you can actually go after, which can involve additional steps like wage garnishment or bank levies depending on your state.
The main pitfall nobody's mentioning: even if you win in small claims court, you get a judgment, but that judgment is just a piece of paper. Your cousin could ignore it, and then you'd have to go through the separate process of trying to enforce it - which might mean garnishing wages, placing liens on property, or hiring a collections agency. That costs more money and time, and if he's already ghosting you, he might not have assets worth pursuing anyway.
That said, the handwritten agreement should absolutely hold up. Judges deal with these constantly and as long as it's clear about the amount, when it was due, and both of you signed it, you've got a solid case. Small claims courts exist for exactly this situation. The filing fee varies by state but usually isn't huge - maybe $100-300 or so depending where you live.
Your best move is probably to send him one more formal communication (email works fine, texts less so) laying out exactly what you're owed, referencing the agreement, and giving him a deadline - maybe 10-14 days. Keep it businesslike, not angry. If he still ghosts, file. It'll put pressure on him and at least you'll have an official record. Just go in with realistic expectations about collecting afterward - sometimes the threat of a judgment is enough to make someone suddenly cooperative, but sometimes it's not.
Log into answer.
