5 answers
Your actual return will swing wildly year to year - anywhere from negative to 15%+ - so fixating on an annual target number is kind of a trap. If you're building something for the long haul, focus on your withdrawal rate instead: if you can live off 3-4% of your portfolio per year, you're probably fine regardless of what the market does that particular year. One thing I haven't seen mentioned is stress-testing your mix against a really bad year - pull up historical data for 2008 or 2022 and run your exact allocation through it, then decide if you can stomach that drawdown without panic-selling, because that's the real test.
The tricky part is that "realistic" changes depending on market conditions and your mix - there's no single answer that holds true year to year. Most people aim for somewhere in the 6-8% range over the long haul with a balanced portfolio, though some years you'll get much more and others you'll lose money.
Looking at what you actually hold matters way more than chasing a magic number. I've got a pretty basic setup - mostly index funds with some bonds - and over the last decade or so I've averaged somewhere around 7-8% when things go smoothly, but I've also eaten 15-20% losses in rough years and that's just part of the deal. The mix is everything: someone 100% in stocks might see double that in good years but get demolished in a downturn, while someone heavy on bonds gets steadier but smaller gains. Honestly if you're doing a true mixed portfolio with stocks and bonds split reasonably, expecting 5-7% annually over the long haul is more grounded than banking on those 8-10% numbers you hear tossed around.
The one thing people often miss is that your withdrawal strategy matters almost as much as your returns - pulling money out during a down year can tank your long-term performance way more than a slightly lower average return would. So if you're relying on this portfolio for income, that's a separate calculation from just "what should I expect to earn," and you might need to be more conservative with your mix or keep more cash on hand.
I've watched people get burned chasing that magic number instead of building something they can actually stick with through the rough years. What nobody talks about enough is your own behavior - whether you panic-sell in a downturn or keep adding money during a crash matters way more than squeezing out an extra percent or two through fancy allocation. If you're genuinely mixed (stocks, bonds, maybe some alternatives), you're probably looking at somewhere between 5-7% on average over decades, but that's useless as a yearly target since you could easily see swings of 20% either direction in any given twelve months.
Your answer
Log into answer.