Why do cafes keep running out of their advertised menu items?

I've noticed this happening a lot lately at coffee shops and brunch spots near me. They'll have something on the menu board, but when you try to order it, they say they're out. Is this a supply chain thing still, or are these places just not ordering enough stock? It's getting frustrating when I'm planning my visit around a specific item.

2 answers

Have you noticed whether it's the same items running out, or does it seem random?

The frustration is real, and it's actually a combination of things rather than just one cause. Most cafes operate on pretty thin margins, so they're walking a tightrope between ordering enough stock and not wasting money on stuff that doesn't sell. If a seasonal item or specialty drink isn't moving as fast as they expected, they'll run out before the next delivery. Supply chain issues have definitely improved since the worst of 2020-2022, but they haven't disappeared entirely - some specialty ingredients or equipment still take longer to source than before. Plus, staffing shortages mean fewer people managing inventory, so things slip through the cracks more often.

The other part of this is just how cafes forecast demand. They're usually making educated guesses about what'll sell on any given day, and they're often wrong. If Tuesday's usually slow but suddenly you and fifty other people show up wanting the same thing, they're caught short. Some places deliberately keep limited stock of high-prep items (like specific pastries or made-to-order sandwiches) to minimize waste, so those items genuinely run out by mid-morning. If there's a particular cafe doing this constantly, it might be worth asking them directly how late their most popular items typically last - some will even hold things for you if you call ahead.

joshua91 asker It's mostly the same items - seasonal drinks and pastries seem to disappear by mid-morning. I usually go around 10 AM, so timing might be the issue.

Do the same items consistently run out, or does it shift day to day? That's actually the key to understanding what's happening at your local spots. If it's always the same thing - like the avocado toast or a specific pastry - they're probably underestimating demand or not reordering enough. But if it's random items that change, you're looking at genuine supply hiccups or spoilage issues that force them to pull things mid-day. Either way, most cafes are still figuring out their ordering rhythm after the chaos of the past few years, so they tend to be conservative with stock to avoid waste, which backfires when something gets popular.

Your answer

Log into answer.