The economy angle makes way more sense than a sudden health awakening. When people tighten their belts, discretionary stuff like candy gets cut first - it's not like anyone's saying "I'm skipping Halloween treats to hit my fitness goals." More likely families are just buying less overall, or skipping the fancy stuff and going for whatever's on sale. That's a pretty normal reaction to wallet pressure.
The thing nobody's mentioning though is that candy sales numbers can be tricky to interpret. A dip this year might look like a trend when it's actually just people buying at different times or places. Plus, there's a timing element - if Halloween falls on a weekday versus weekend, that shifts when people shop. And inflation's been wild, so lower unit sales might just mean people are grabbing smaller bags instead of bulk boxes. The actual amount of money spent could tell a totally different story than the volume numbers retailers are throwing around.
Worth watching what happens next year, but I wouldn't read too much into a single season. Economic downturns tend to bounce back, and candy consumption is pretty sticky - people find ways to keep buying what they enjoy. The health trend stuff, if it's real at all, would show up slowly over years, not as a dramatic drop in one Halloween.