Can a tenant refuse to pay for a building's major renovation if they're renting and not the owner?

mihaylova1986 RU 🌱 Newbie 👁 124 ⚑ Report Laws

I've been living in an apartment under a rental agreement for three years now. The apartment owner received an invoice for major repairs to the building's common property and now he's demanding that I pay my share. Is that right? How is the responsibility for such payments actually regulated between the owner and the tenant?

4 answers

★ Best answer

The homeowner is responsible for major repairs and must pay for them themselves, rather than shifting the costs to tenants. This applies to general maintenance work - roof, load-bearing walls, shared utilities. When you signed the rental agreement, the owner already knew about these obligations. It's different if the contract explicitly states that you'll pay part of the major repairs, but even then such terms are often deemed unfair, and a court can challenge them.

The owner sometimes tries to pass expenses on to tenants, saying you're the ones living there anyway. But that's not their right - if an apartment is rented out, all costs for maintaining the building remain the owner's responsibility. Your share of utilities (water, electricity, heating) is one thing, major repairs are quite another. Look carefully at your contract and check whether there are any special conditions regarding major repairs. If such conditions exist and you don't understand them, it's worth consulting with a lawyer. If there's nothing like that in the contract, feel free to refuse and explain to the owner that this is their obligation.

According to the law, the owner of the building is obligated to pay for major repairs, not the tenant - it's their expense as the property owner. The owner can try to shift this cost onto you through the rental agreement, but only if it explicitly states that you're paying for major repairs; without such a clause, the demand is illegal. Check your rental agreement - if there's no condition about sharing major repair expenses, feel free to refuse and suggest the owner deal with it themselves or through the management company.

Don't just agree to pay without checking your lease - that's the most common mistake people make. Technically, major repairs are the landlord's responsibility, not the tenant's, but your lease might have terms that split that responsibility differently. I know someone who rented out her apartment and specifically wrote into the lease that major repairs would be split 50/50 - and the tenant agreed because he got a discount on rent in exchange. If your lease doesn't say anything about it, the owner can't just demand it from you; you need to point out that it's their cost of ownership.

The main thing is to check your lease agreement - it might have clauses that shift major repair costs onto you, and technically that would be legal. Most people in these situations just hand money over to the landlord without actually reading the document, and then regret it later. If the lease says nothing about major repairs, then yes, it's the landlord's responsibility, but if it does say something - you signed that line, so you'll have to pay.

Your answer

Log into answer.