How do I choose the right fishing line for different types of fish?

GI giulia95 IT 🔍 Enthusiast 👁 82 ⚑ Report Fishing

I'm starting to fish on the Ticino near my house and I'm a bit confused about the different types of line. I've seen they sell nylon, fluorocarbon, and braided line, but I don't know which to use for trout and perch. Can someone explain the main differences?

5 answers

★ Best answer

It's not like there's a universally "right" line because it depends on so many variables, but generally nylon is the best compromise for beginners: it's cheap, holds up well and absorbs the shock of sudden strikes. For river trout fluorocarbon is more invisible underwater so it can help if the fish are wary, whereas braid is more sensitive and lets you feel bites better, but it's less forgiving if you mess up your technique. Personally I'd start with a good nylon in 0.18-0.20 mm for both trout and perch, and see how it goes; the rest you figure out by practicing, it's not rocket science 😄

The trick is to start with nylon and then move to fluorocarbon once you know what you're doing better, because fluorocarbon is more invisible underwater but it costs twice as much and requires more attention. I actually started out on the Ticino years ago with just nylon and honestly for trout it works great, especially if you use diameters that aren't too thick (maybe 0.18-0.20); perch though is a bit more wary and that's when I saw differences when I switched to decent quality nylon, even more so when a friend got me to try fluorocarbon on his rod. I'd only factor in braided line after all that because it's excellent for distance and sensitivity but it's more visible and if you're not experienced you risk tying knots badly.

For trout and perch on the Ticino, start right off with braided line if you really want to do well - don't wait! Braided gives you extraordinary sensitivity to feel the bites, especially with trout which often strikes delicately, and it doesn't twist up like monofilament when you're fishing in current (which is your situation on the river). Yeah, it costs a bit more, but if you're just starting out it's worth doing things right from the beginning rather than throwing money away swapping out line. But if your budget is super tight, monofilament works great - just as soon as you scrape together a few euros, switch to braided and you'll immediately see the difference!

On the choice of line, I'd say don't let yourself be too influenced by people who say "switch to braided right away": for trout and perch in the Ticino, monofilament is still the most sensible solution when you're starting out, and it's not a downgrade. You need a line that forgives your beginner mistakes, and monofilament does exactly that. It has natural elasticity, absorbs sudden strikes, costs next to nothing if you break it while you're learning, and works really well in rivers. Start with a diameter around 0.16-0.20 for trout and 0.20-0.25 for perch, and you're already getting good results.

Fluorocarbon makes sense when you're more aware of what you're doing: it's less visible to fish because it has a refractive index similar to water, useful for crystal-clear waters or wary fish, but it's stiffer, tends to dig into the spool, and costs honestly three times as much. Braided is a whole different story: yeah, it has incredible sensitivity because it has no elasticity, but that's exactly why it requires decent technique so you don't snap the line with sudden jerks. Starting with braided on the Ticino in summer or fall, when the water's fast and the trout are reactive, is basically just unnecessary punishment.

Start easy with monofilament, practice for a few months, and when you really feel the difference between a light bite and a hard one, then you can eventually try the others. On your local river you'll have already learned where the holes are and how to move around, and at that point the right line will make the real difference.

At home I also started out with some confusion about fishing lines, then I figured out it really depends on what you're actually after. Nylon is the sensible starting point for the Ticino: it's cheap, easy to handle, and doesn't stress you out. Abrasion resistance is decent for rivers with rocks and branches, and if you lose your terminal you won't cry over it. Fluorocarbon is more invisible underwater (useful if the fish are suspicious), but it's stiff, fragile at knots, and like the person who wrote before said, it costs quite a bit. Braided line is something else entirely: super high sensitivity, zero stretch, you feel every movement. The problem is it's visible, cuts like a razor if you cast it wrong, and with wary trout it can make a real negative difference.

On the Ticino with trout and perch my approach has simply been nylon for pretty much everything. If things are going well and you want to push it, then maybe you use braided as your mainline and attach a leader in fluorocarbon or nylon below, so you get the best of both worlds. But at the start of the season it's not worth wasting energy on braided: you'll spend more time cleaning tangles off your reel than actually fishing. Once you know the river better and how your fish behave, then start experimenting with different materials.

Your answer

Log into answer.