8 answers

★ Best answer

Don't make drastic water changes all at once because that causes more fluctuations. What works is doing more frequent but smaller changes (20% two or three times a week), adding a substrate that stabilizes the pH like aragonite sand, and checking that you don't have too much uneaten food or decomposing plants acidifying the water.

The substrate and decorations in your tank have way more influence on pH fluctuations than you'd think 🐠 If you've got a lot of organic matter breaking down or a really old substrate, it's gonna stay unstable even if you're doing constant water changes. Try cleaning the substrate really well with a siphon during your water changes, and if you have live plants, make sure they're healthy because dead ones acidify the water. A trick that works pretty well is adding a bit of peat or coral sand (depending on whether you want to lower or raise the pH) in a mesh bag inside your filter - it acts as a buffer without any radical swings.

What almost nobody checks is the water's buffering capacity, and that's what actually keeps the pH stable. Depending on where you live, your tap water already comes with certain dissolved minerals that help, but if it's too soft or too hard the fluctuations are going to be a mess. Try doing a hardness test (GH) along with the pH, because a tank with very low hardness goes crazy with anything that happens inside it.

How long have you had that aquarium, and what kind of tap water do you use? Because honestly, constant fluctuations almost always come from not having enough "buffering" in the water, and that depends a lot on your area.

In my case I have plants in pots and I've noticed that when the substrate fills up with food scraps and dead leaves, the pH becomes a mess 😅 So what I do is clean the bottom really well with a siphon every time I do a water change, not just skim over it. But that's the decoration thing they mentioned above. What's really missing is getting to the root of the problem: the water coming from your tap. If your water has low hardness or few dissolved minerals, it's naturally going to fluctuate a lot because there's nothing to "hold up" the pH. Try measuring your water hardness (or alkalinity/KH) with a test kit - if it's too low, there's your answer.

What you can do is add a specific buffer for aquariums (there are different types depending on whether you need to raise or lower pH) or consider mixing some distilled water with your tap water if it's too hard. It also helps a lot to have plenty of live plants or lots of established bacteria in the filter, because that stabilizes the system naturally. And yeah, small frequent changes like they said above is the right call - that 30% all at once per week is probably making things worse. Try 15-20% every three or four days and see if it improves 🌱

tigre_javier asker Thanks! I've had the tank for about 8 months, I use tap water. I'm going to measure the hardness and try more frequent, smaller water changes.

pH fluctuations in small aquariums are a pain because the water doesn't have enough volume to "buffer" chemical changes. I had the same problem with a tank similar to yours at my place, and what really worked was checking what was inside: I had an old substrate full of detritus that was constantly acidifying the water. Once I cleaned the bottom properly and replaced part of the substrate with fresh material, the pH stabilized much more. Also, pay attention to your tap water's pH - if it varies from day to day or by season, that's what's causing the problem. Some places have really "soft" water that can't handle changes, so if that's your case, it's worth trying calcareous rocks or a bit of marine salt to give your aquarium some buffering capacity.

Avoid doing really big or really frequent water changes because you'll just end up creating more chaos than stability! What's actually going to save you is checking what's in your aquarium: if you have live plants, those are incredible for stabilizing pH because they consume the acids that build up; if you don't have any, you could add a couple and you'd see the difference right away. Also pay attention to whether there's uneaten food or dead leaves piling up, because that acidifies the water a lot. With an aquarium as small as yours, adding a handful of limestone (just that!) or some calcium-based substrate could help you keep that chemical "buffer" that prevents wild fluctuations.

Whenever I have to look into something, I always end up questioning what's really going on, and in your case I suspect the tap water you're using has poor buffering capacity - that's what people usually overlook. The dissolved minerals in the water are what keep the pH stable, not just water changes; if your tap water is "soft," you're going to get constant fluctuations no matter what you do.

What I'd do is test the water hardness (KH specifically) before throwing more solutions into the tank. If it's too low, you can add a substrate or rock that releases minerals slowly, or just use a buffer product to stabilize it. Small, frequent changes help, but without hardness in the water it's like trying to fix it with your hands tied.

First of all, check how often you're cleaning the filter; if it's really dirty it accumulates organic matter that acidifies the water constantly and that's why the pH won't stabilize even if you do regular water changes. Once you've got the filter clean (with no buildup), the tap water itself is what's going to determine how much stability you can achieve - if it comes out really soft or really hard, that's going to affect everything. Tropical fish generally can handle variations as long as they're gradual, so what matters is that the pH doesn't swing wildly from one day to the next, rather than keeping it at an exact number. Also consider whether there are plants in the aquarium; they absorb and release acids in ways that affect the pH during the day and night.

Your answer

Log into answer.