3 answers

★ Best answer

The secret's honestly just time and good ingredients - your nan probably simmered a whole chicken (or at least bones and meat together) for at least 1-2 hours, maybe longer, which extracts all that collagen and gelatin that makes it actually nourishing and gives it that silky mouthfeel.

Don't skip the aromatics (onion, carrot, celery) and maybe some bay leaf or thyme, and honestly the magic is in not rushing it - low and slow beats high and fast every time.

If you want to get closer to what she made, try asking her now while you still can, or at least have her walk you through it once; there's probably some small thing you're missing, whether it's the type of chicken she used, how much salt, or some herb she threw in.

One more thing - homemade stock made from the bones after you've pulled the meat off will blow anything store-bought out of the water for that deep, rich flavor.

The other person nailed it - time is basically everything here. Your nan wasn't doing anything fancy, she was just letting a whole chicken (or a good pile of bones with some meat attached) just hang out in water for literally hours. That's where the magic happens. The collagen in the bones breaks down and turns into gelatin, which gives you that silky, rich mouthfeel that makes it actually taste like *something*, not just hot water with chicken bits in it.

Here's what I'd do: throw a whole chicken or a bunch of bones/carcass in a big pot with cold water, bring it to a boil, then immediately turn it down to a gentle simmer. Skim off the gross foam that rises to the top in the first few minutes - that's impurities and it makes a difference. Then just... leave it alone for like 2-3 hours minimum. Throw in some carrots, celery, onion (cut in half, doesn't need to be fancy), maybe some garlic, a few peppercorns, salt. Don't go crazy with seasonings because you want to taste the actual chicken. If your nan was old school she might've added parsnip or parsley too. The long simmer does all the flavor work for you.

The trick most people miss is that they're impatient or they use chicken breasts instead of a whole bird. Breasts are too lean - you need bones and skin and the whole situation to get that deep flavor. Also strain it properly when you're done and honestly, let it cool in the fridge overnight if you can. The fat congeals on top and you can see exactly what you've made. That's the real deal. Your nan probably made it the night before too, which is why it tasted so good when she heated it up again.

I made a batch last winter when I was feeling pretty rough, and it hit different from the stuff I'd tried before. The thing that changed everything was actually using a whole chicken instead of just breasts or pre-made stock. I threw the whole bird in a pot with water, onions, carrots, celery - the basics - and just let it go for a solid 2-3 hours on low heat. The meat gets super tender and falls off the bone, and all those connective tissues break down into gelatin, which gives you that silky, rich mouthfeel that canned broth can never match.

The other thing people miss is not rushing it or cranking up the heat. Low and slow is the move. Once it's simmering, you can basically ignore it - just skim off the foam that rises in the first 20 minutes or so. I season near the end, not the beginning, because the broth concentrates as water evaporates and you don't want it ending up salty. Fresh herbs at the very end (parsley, dill if your nan used it) make a real difference too. Some folks add a splash of lemon juice or a bay leaf during cooking. Your nan probably had her own little tweaks, but the core thing she was doing was just giving the chicken time to give up all its flavor into the water.

Your answer

Log into answer.