5 answers

★ Best answer

The best thing is to use a cold chisel or a flat chisel with a hammer to lift the broken tile little by little from the edges, being careful not to hit the healthy pieces next to it. Once you take out the tile, scrape away the old mortar from the floor well with the cold chisel to leave a flat, clean surface. Then apply fresh mortar, place the new tile aligning it with the others and wait for it to set before stepping on it; if the tiles have grout lines (those spaces between pieces), fill them with grout after the mortar is dry. One tip: go slowly on the first few hits so you don't chip the adjacent tiles, and if you need to replace two that are next to each other, remove both so the new grout line comes out even.

Don't try to yank the tile out all at once or hit it straight with a hammer, because you'll end up breaking the adjacent ones and then you'll have to replace half your kitchen. What works well is starting from the edges with a cold chisel or a flat chisel, hitting gently and progressively while you lift it little by little. If the tile is stuck on good, the work is slow but steady: slide the tool underneath at an angle, press without force, and when you see it starting to give, move from side to side.

A trick most people don't mention: before you start, use a small angle grinder or a ceramic saw and make a shallow cut in the grout line between the broken tile and the good ones. This gives you a clear boundary and keeps the chisel from slipping and chipping the neighboring pieces. If you don't have a grinder, even with a utility knife you can deepen the grout line enough so the chisel stays on track.

Once you get the tile out, scrape all the old adhesive off the floor really well because if you leave lumps you're going to have trouble getting the new one level with the surrounding tiles. Then put fresh adhesive down, place the new tile and make sure it's aligned with the ones around it before it dries. Let it dry for however long the adhesive instructions say before you step on it.

Basically you need to start loosening the grout (that white stuff between tiles) with a screwdriver or a pointed tool so the broken tile loses its grip, and then you carefully work the chisel in from the edges. What nobody mentions is that after you remove the piece you have to clean out all the old material from the floor and the back of the new tiles, because if you leave dust or bits of old grout, the new tile won't adhere properly and it can come loose in just a few months 😅 It's work that takes patience but it's worth doing it right.

Once you get the broken tile out, you'll have old adhesive underneath, and that's what a lot of people forget to clean properly - if you don't do it, the new tile won't sit flat or stick correctly. Scrape off all that residue with a chisel until the surface is as even as possible, and then check with a straightedge that there are no gaps or unevenness. Only then do you apply the new adhesive and lay the replacement tile.

Do you have access to a tape measure or something to measure the thickness of the tile? Because besides everything people say about removing the piece with a chisel and hammer, what nobody mentions is that when you clean the old adhesive off the floor you need to leave the base as flat as possible, not just free of debris. If lumps remain or the old adhesive is too uneven, the new tile will end up sunken or raised, and that becomes a problem later because it collects water or shifts. I go over it several times with a metal scraper until I get it almost level, and then I use flexible adhesive (not plain cement) that gives you some wiggle room during installation.

Patricia95 asker Yeah, I have a tape measure. Thanks for the tip about keeping the base flat, I hadn't thought of that. I'm going to use a scraper and flexible adhesive.

Your answer

Log into answer.