Calcium carbonate soda and wood ash are only half-measures, because they temporarily alkalize the soil, but the effect wears off quickly, especially if your soil is naturally acidic 😅 Iron sulfate works better, but it's not that straightforward either: the substance really does help, but you need to apply it at the right time and smartly so you don't burn the lawn. The key is understanding why moss ended up in your yard in the first place.
In shady spots, moss grows not just because of acidity, but also because grass grows slower there, competes weaker, air gets stagnant, and moisture lingers longer. That's why mechanical removal combined with proper leaf cleanup in the fall actually works - you remove the old layer, let the grass breathe and dry faster. Then definitely reseed that area with shade-tolerant grasses, they'll fill the space and push out the moss. And yeah, if you can - thin out the tree canopy, light works wonders.
From organic options, I used iron sulfate in spring when the soil warmed up, but applied it spot-on to the most overgrown patches, not across the whole lawn. I got results, but exactly because at the same time I improved drainage and reseeded the grass 🌱 Without that - it's just treating the symptoms.