If you can't prove something exists, does that mean it doesn't?

Frank US 🛠️ Specialist 👁 58 ⚑ Report Philosophy

I've been thinking about this after reading about quantum mechanics and how observation affects reality. Like, if nobody's looking at something, is it really there? And how is that different from something that just doesn't exist at all? It seems like there's a real philosophical difference but I can't quite pin it down.

2 answers

The gap between "we can't prove it exists" and "it doesn't exist" is huge - absence of evidence isn't evidence of absence, especially when our tools or access might be limited. Quantum mechanics is trickier than it sounds though: observation doesn't make particles pop into existence from nothing, but rather the act of measuring forces a particle to "pick" a definite state from a range of possibilities, which is a constraint on reality, not a creation of it.

I ran into this exact problem trying to figure out why my tank plants kept dying in low light - I couldn't see algae spores, but they were definitely there doing damage. The real issue is that "can't prove" and "doesn't exist" are answering different questions: one's about our evidence or tools, the other's about reality itself. With quantum mechanics specifically, the confusion comes from mixing up what the math describes (probability waves collapsing on observation) with what's "really there" before we look - physicists still argue about that interpretation, but most agree the particles exist whether observed or not; the observation just changes *which* property we can measure. So something can be genuinely real but undetectable with current methods, undetectable forever due to physical limits, or just completely nonexistent - and we need different reasons to believe or dismiss each case.

Your answer

Log into answer.