Your brother's not completely wrong, but it's more nuanced than that. The real difference really shows up if you drink your juice right away with a regular centrifuge - yeah, you do lose stuff because of oxidation and heat. Now I've tested both: with the slow juicer you really keep better color and fresher taste even after a few hours, whereas with the centrifuge you gotta drink it within twenty minutes or it's done for. As for the exact nutrients, honestly nobody really knows the exact percentage you lose, it's not like you'd see a tangible difference drinking a glass. The real thing is: do you have the time and make juices regularly? Invest in the slow juicer. You're in a rush and just want your juices quick? The centrifuge does the job, especially since you'll actually use it.