Reinvest the dividends - full stop. over 10-15 years the compounding effect is genuinely massive, and since your broker charges nothing for it, there's literally no friction. if you took the cash instead you'd either spend it or have to manually feed it back in and pay $5 each time, which eats into gains fast. the math is simple: every dollar reinvested starts earning its own dividends next quarter, and that snowballs.
here's the hack nobody mentions though - check if your broker lets you set different reinvestment rules for different holdings. some platforms let you reinvest automatically on certain funds but take cash on others. if one of your positions is already overweight in your portfolio, you can let the others compound while drawing cash from the one you want to trim. keeps things balanced without selling and triggering capital gains.
one thing to watch: make sure you're tracking all those reinvested dividends for taxes. your broker should send a statement showing every reinvestment, and you'll owe tax on the full dividend amount whether you reinvested it or pocketed it. don't get caught off guard come April. over 15 years of compounding, that paperwork adds up, but it's worth the hassle compared to what you'll actually gain.