4 answers
I did it two summers ago and honestly the pass saved my trip. I was in the south for ten days with my husband, we wanted to see Naples, the Amalfi Coast, Salerno, a bit of Basilicata. We made like eight or nine train trips between regional and intercity trains, and buying individual tickets would've cost a lot more. The pass made sense for us because we weren't staying in one place, but the calculation other people make is right: you really need to make a lot of trips close together.
What they don't usually tell you is that it also depends on how you organize your days. If you decide to stay two days in Naples and then two days in Salerno, maybe you make fewer long trips and the pass doesn't make sense. But if you're the type who wants to try everything and hop from place to place, then yeah, it's worth it. Also keep in mind that regional trains in the south are slower, so sometimes you prefer the intercity which costs more than a regional, and that's where the pass really starts giving you an advantage. Anyway, the real advice is to do the math beforehand on the Trenitalia website: add up the price of all the tickets you think you'll buy, and compare it to the cost of the pass. If you save even just twenty or thirty euros, in my opinion it's worth it for the convenience of not having to worry about individual purchases.
It depends on how much you plan to move around and for how many days. If you're in the south for a week and think you'll take the train 4-5 times, it might be worth it, especially if you include long routes like Naples-Palermo. The problem is that regional trains in the south are slow and often cost very little individually, so if you're only making a few short trips you might end up spending less buying tickets one by one. Check the pass prices carefully for the number of days you need and look at single fares before you decide.
The real trick is calculating the exact cost of individual tickets before you decide, because the pass only makes sense if you're really doing a lot of traveling in a short amount of time. I've used it a couple of times on long vacations in the south and discovered that it's usually worth it only if you're really the type who jumps from one city to another every day - otherwise you end up paying for routes you won't actually take.
What a lot of people don't consider is that southern Italy, especially if you're heading toward Sicily or Calabria, has frequent delays and connections that aren't exactly smooth between lines. If your trip is more laid-back, like staying a week in Naples and maybe a quick day trip to Salerno or Positano, you save more money buying individual tickets when you need them. The pass really makes sense if your strategy is like: Bari on Monday, Lecce on Tuesday, Taranto on Wednesday - basically a crazy pace.
Another tip is to check if there are regional offers for the specific area you're in, sometimes they're cheaper than the national pass. And anyway, if you're traveling on slow regional trains the price is already low on its own, so the pass advantage drops even more.
the trenitalia pass in the south is less worth it than it seems, especially if you're not already used to planning every move. regional trains are pretty slow (like Naples-Palermo eats up your whole day) and intercity tickets already cost next to nothing if you book them a few days ahead.
what nobody mentions is that the pass works better in the north, where distances are short and trains run frequently. down south you end up waiting forever at the station or just flying/driving instead because it's twice as fast. unless you're staying 2-3 weeks and actually moving to different places every single day, it's better to just look for discounted single tickets online a few weeks in advance. it costs less, zero stress planning everything around the pass, and you pick decent departure times without compromises.
if you really want the pass because you hate booking tickets one by one, fine, but don't expect to save a ton. it's more of a mental convenience than a good deal.
Your answer
Log into answer.