2 answers
No-frost models consume considerably more electricity because the compressor runs continuously to maintain that cold air circulation and prevent frost buildup, while traditional frost models only turn on when they need to. If your electricity bill matters to you, a regular frost model will save you a decent amount each month, though obviously you'll have to defrost it manually from time to time.
Did you expect them to consume the same? The reality is more nuanced than what the previous answer says. No-frost models do theoretically use more energy, but the difference in your bill probably won't be as dramatic as some people think, especially if your old frost fridge is 10+ years old; the new no-frost ones are pretty efficient. One thing nobody mentions: if you have a no-frost, make sure the air vents aren't blocked by food or ice buildup on the sides - that forces the compressor to work harder and kills any savings. With frost models, on the other hand, defrosting regularly (every 3-4 months if you see a lot of ice) really helps keep energy consumption down.
Your answer
Log into answer.