I want to replace my old mattress, but I'm not sure what to choose. There's a huge selection in the stores, and the salespeople contradict each other. I have back problems, so I need to sleep on an orthopedic one. Which option is more reliable and durable?
Both options can be orthopedic - it all depends not on whether there are springs, but on the quality of the filling and the overall construction. Spring mattresses are usually cheaper and feel more familiar, but foam or latex-free mattresses (especially with memory foam or latex) adapt better to the curves of your spine and distribute weight more evenly - this is especially important if you have back problems.
As for durability, they're about the same if you don't cut corners: a cheap spring mattress can sag within a couple of years, while a quality foam mattress will last just as long. The main thing when choosing is to actually lie on it in the store for at least five minutes and check that your spine stays in a neutral position, not sagging or arching.
# Translation
The main thing is don't focus on the construction type - go by how it feels and what's good for your back. I personally believed in the miracle of springs for a long time until I actually tried different options myself. Turned out comfort doesn't depend on whether there are springs or not, but on how well the mattress supports your spine in your actual sleeping position.
For back problems, here's my advice: go to a store, take your shoes off, and lie on each mattress for at least a minute or two in your normal sleeping position. Don't worry about looking weird - it actually matters. Pay attention to whether you feel your lower back sagging or, on the flip side, if the firmness is pressing down. A good orthopedic mattress should follow the contours of your body but not sink in.
As for durability - you've got to be honest about the materials. Cheap spring mattresses really do often start squeaking and sagging. Foam-free ones with quality filling like coconut or high-density foam hold up pretty well, but that also depends on the price. Look at the manufacturer's warranty - that's a good sign of how confident they are in their product.
Log into answer.
