6 answers

★ Best answer

I understand the logic behind your question, but there's an important nuance here: IIHS results depend heavily on which specific model you're looking at. The same crossover released in different generations or for different markets can perform very differently in tests. If you found information that three popular models failed testing, check the model year and market version - it might be referring to generations that are no longer in production or regional variants that aren't sold anymore.

The second pitfall is IIHS itself. While it's an authoritative organization, it tests vehicles by its own standards, which in some respects are stricter than international ones. A car might perform poorly on an IIHS frontal crash test but still pass European Euro NCAP testing fine and have current active safety systems in the cabin (automatic emergency braking, adaptive cruise control, etc.), which often save lives in real-world situations better than good body structure.

If you're seriously shopping for a car, don't just look at one rating - check the databases from NHTSA (US), Euro NCAP (Europe), and see what's there. Sometimes the results diverge, and the full picture gives you a more objective understanding of a specific model's actual safety.

IIHS crash tests are a really serious indicator, and if a car fails the frontal or side collision tests, that's definitely reason to think twice. Though when choosing a car, I wouldn't just look at specific test ratings - I'd look at the bigger picture: real owner reviews, results from other organizations (NHTSA, Euro NCAP), and safety feature equipment. Name specific models and I can tell you something else useful about them, because each crash test only shows part of the picture.

The thing is, "popular" and "unsafe" aren't quite the same thing. A car can fail a specific IIHS test, but still have good results on other safety criteria, plus active driver assistance systems that often prevent accidents altogether. It's more important to look at the big picture - not just crash tests, but also real-world accident statistics, reliability reviews for the electronics and braking systems. A crash test shows what happens in the worst-case scenario, not how often people actually get into trouble in these cars.

It's important to remember that IIHS tests cars under very specific conditions - at 40 mph at a particular angle. In real life, crashes happen differently: at different angles, different speeds, with different obstacles. A car that failed the IIHS front-end test might handle a side-impact collision or a hard stop before an obstacle just fine. So one failed test isn't a verdict - it's a signal to dig deeper.

Another thing: if a model failed a test years ago, that data might be outdated. Manufacturers are constantly improving their designs, reinforcing frames, changing materials. One generation of an SUV might get low scores, while the next one gets good ones. You should check the results for your specific year and generation, not judge based on old data.

And one more point: active safety - collision warning systems, automatic braking, stability control - is often more important than passive protection in real-world conditions because it prevents the crash from happening in the first place. An SUV with solid electronics but average crash-test results might be safer in everyday driving than a car with excellent crash-test protection but no driver-assistance features.

Tell me - which safety sources do you prioritize yourself, IIHS or something else? Because honestly, there's a trap in the question itself: IIHS is a serious standard, but it's not the only one! European EuroNCAP crash tests are often tougher, and there's also NHTSA in the US. A car that failed one specific IIHS test can still have five-star ratings by other standards. Plus versions for different markets can differ - a crossover that did pretty well in an EuroNCAP test might perform worse in IIHS simply because the structure was tweaked a bit to meet American requirements.

Second - yeah, the colleagues above made a good point about test specifics! Crash tests are actually pretty artificial scenarios. IIHS tests frontal impact at 40 mph at an angle, side impact, roof… it's all very controlled scenarios. In real life people hit things at different speeds, different angles, and random objects can jam into the car. That's why I'd also look at active safety - whether the collision avoidance system actually works, how good the stability control is! Sometimes a car with slightly worse passive protection but decent electronics turns out to be safer in real life.

Don't get hung up on a single test as the ultimate truth - IIHS is a good indicator, but it's not the complete picture of safety. What's easy to miss in these comparisons: results can vary significantly depending on the trim level and what options are included (the same model with a cheap safety package and the luxury version are basically two different cars in reality).

Also check out actual crash data from insurance companies and NHTSA - that shows you how cars actually perform in real accidents, not lab conditions. Sometimes a car doesn't ace the crash tests, but on the road it performs better thanks to active safety features and body structure.

Your answer

Log into answer.