No, neither apps nor actual cards can predict the future - your girlfriend is right about that. I don't mean it harshly, but there's really no difference between an app and physical cards, because both come down to the same thing: random results that you then interpret. The app has no magical advantage, but no disadvantage either. A random card combination is just as random whether it's displayed digitally or whether you pull it from an actual deck.
What you're probably experiencing is what your girlfriend is describing - confirmation bias and what some people call "the Forer effect." Tarot interpretations are intentionally vague and ambiguous so they feel fitting for almost any situation. If a card says "change is coming" and you're going through a tough time right now, you'll read that as confirmation. The cards that don't fit, you forget quickly. And when you consciously work through a decision yourself - while using the app - you're helping yourself, not the cards.
That doesn't mean the app can't help you, but only because it forces you to think about a problem, not because the cards have supernatural abilities. If the app helps you think more carefully about your problems, that's fine - but it's a tool for self-reflection, not for divination. For important decisions, it's better to rely on your own thinking instead.