Cryptocurrencies as investments - worth it or too risky?

SA Sabine DE 🔍 Enthusiast 👁 193 ⚑ Report Investing

I'm 28 and I've been thinking for a while now about whether I should invest a small part of my savings in Bitcoin or Ethereum. A lot of my friends have done it, but I'm not sure if it's really a good idea or if I should just put my money into regular ETFs instead.

9 answers

★ Best answer

I'd be honest and say the question shouldn't be "crypto or ETFs" but rather "how much crypto, if at all". The distinction matters: with ETFs, you know what you've got - a diversified portfolio with traceable value development. With crypto you're paying for volatility and hope, not a business model. That doesn't mean it's stupid, but it's fundamentally different.

If you're really interested, then only use money you can completely lose without it changing your life. Maybe 5% of your savings max, preferably less. Here's a practical trick most people don't do: buy your position all at once and then stop checking constantly. People often lose their nerve because they check daily and panic at dips. If you're going to get emotional about it anyway, you shouldn't bother starting.

Your friends who've done it probably only tell you about their gains - confirmation bias is real. ETFs are boring, but they work. At 28 you've got time for long-term thinking, and over many years ETFs almost always beat crypto. If you notice this stuff distracts you during the day or you're sleeping poorly, it's definitely not right for you.

With crypto you just have to accept that the volatility is brutal - your money can swing 30, 40, or more percent within weeks, while ETFs tend to grow at a steady pace. If you can handle that psychologically and it's really just a small part of your savings (say 5-10%), it might make sense to get to know the thing, but I wouldn't make it your main strategy. Most people who made money with it either got in early or just got lucky - it's never reliable. If you want to save long-term and stress-free, ETFs are way more sensible.

The real question is more like: can you afford to have that money tied up for several years, and if necessary, watch it shrink by 50, 60 percent without it destroying you financially or psychologically? If yes, then there's nothing against putting a smaller portion in there (let's say 5-10 percent of your savings) - that's more like play money than a serious investment. If no, or if you're going to need the money in the foreseeable future, then ETFs really are the better choice, because they fluctuate way less wildly and you'll sleep a lot better at night.

What actually made you consider this now - is it just because your friends are doing it, or have you looked into the topic yourself too?

Don't do this: put all your eggs in one basket or invest because your friends are doing it. That's probably the most common mistake. If you're genuinely unsure, that's a good signal you should understand more before you get into it. And this is really important - never invest money you'll need in the next few years.

On basic strategy: it's not really either-or. A lot of people do well putting the bulk of it (say 80-90%) into solid ETFs and then maybe reserving 5-10% for more speculative stuff like crypto - basically as a separate pot where it hurts if things go wrong, but it doesn't destroy your whole life. For me personally, I started out experimenting with small amounts I could afford to lose, and that's how I learned what the volatility actually feels like. Not in the abstract, but psychologically. That helps you figure out whether your nerves can handle it.

The point some people here are making is important: it's less about "is crypto good or bad" and more about your actual situation. Do you have an emergency fund? How stable is your income? How long can you realistically wait without needing the money? If the answer to all that is "kind of problematic," then you should really stick to the basics with ETFs first. But if you're in a position where some of your savings can work for years and you can sleep soundly knowing it could drop by 50% - then a smaller crypto allocation could make sense, but I mean really small.

Just do a simple test: invest 500 or 1000 euros in crypto and watch how you feel over the next six months when the price drops by 20 percent. That's way more telling than just thinking about it in theory and wondering if you can handle it. If you lose sleep over it or keep nervously checking the charts, you've got your answer - stick with ETFs instead. But if you're cool with it and it doesn't mess with your head, you'll know you can probably handle it psychologically, and you could go for a bigger stake if needed.

The problem is really that most people who say "crypto is awesome" go dead silent when things go down. My friends told me in 2021 how incredible it is, and in 2022 nobody wanted to talk about it. If you can actually sleep soundly even when your investment suddenly disappears - okay, maybe give it a shot. But psychologically that's a totally different league than ETFs.

What the others didn't mention: it's also about your life situation. At 28 you've got time, that's your advantage. Long-term, 5-10% of your savings could be in crypto if the rest is solid (emergency fund, ETFs for retirement, all that). But if you need the money in the short term or you're just starting to save, that's the wrong time.

My advice: forget your friends. Start with the boring ETFs until you've got a solid foundation. Then, if you really want to understand how crypto works (not speculate, but actually understand), try it with a smaller amount. That way you can learn without the stress.

What often gets overlooked: even if you're only investing a small amount, you need the mental capacity to deal with it - checking news, understanding market movements, not panic-selling 😅 With ETFs, all that happens in the background. If you notice that crypto news is constantly distracting you or you feel obligated to keep researching, that's already a sign it's causing you too much headache. At 28, you've still got time - there's no rush to build a solid ETF portfolio first and decide later whether you want to set aside a fraction for more speculative stuff.

What would your plan be if you needed money in two years and Bitcoin had just dropped by half - could you handle that or would it put you in serious trouble? That's really the only question that matters. If you don't actually need the money and it doesn't bother you if it's temporarily gone, then there's nothing wrong with putting in a smaller amount - but smaller is really the key word here, not money you actually need.

If you're really unsure, just put in a tiny amount - so small that you could lose it all without a problem and it wouldn't hurt. That takes the psychological pressure off and you can learn on the side how it feels without sabotaging yourself. Most people who lost money with crypto didn't go broke because they invested too little, but because they risked too much and then panic-sold - so better to start conservative.

Your answer

Log into answer.