2 answers

★ Best answer

It's true that it's hard to say with valerian and passionflower because the effect is often subtle and it takes time to see a real difference.

The problem is that if you're taking other stuff at the same time like your mom with magnesium, you don't know what's actually helping.

A lot of people feel an improvement but it could be placebo or just because you're paying attention to your mental health.

If your panic attacks are serious, it's really worth talking to a pro instead of testing plants for months without knowing if it's even working.

Herbal medicine can help, but you shouldn't expect miracles, and your problem is exactly what you're saying - with valerian, passionflower AND magnesium all at the same time, you have no idea which one is doing what. Studies show these plants do have an effect, like they can calm you down a bit, but it's often pretty mild and it varies a lot from person to person. For actual panic attacks, it's honestly too weak - you'd really benefit from talking to someone qualified (therapist, doctor) instead of staying in the dark with herbs, because two months is a lot of time to waste if it doesn't work well enough for you.

Your answer

Log into answer.