From what people are actually saying beyond just the review scores, the world design does seem to hit different this time. Folks aren't just parroting marketing - they're noticing specific stuff like NPCs having daily routines that feel organic, environmental storytelling baked into the smallest details, and the way the city reacts to what you do. That said, yeah, there's always a launch honeymoon where everything feels fresh, so it's hard to know if that "lived-in" feeling will hold up after 50+ hours or if it'll start feeling repetitive like open-world games tend to do.
The hype seems more grounded than usual though because people aren't just excited about raw graphics or gunplay - they're talking about world-building quality in a way that suggests Rockstar actually nailed something fundamental about immersion. Whether that justifies the full purchase price depends on what you want. If you're the type who gets genuinely into exploring a world and finding emergent moments, it probably delivers. If you just want a polished story experience, you might burn through it and feel like it was overkill on the environmental detail work. The Australian players who've had it longer seem consistent about one thing though: it's solid, not overhyped into disappointment territory at least.