I saw these machines on TikTok, like knitting machines that promise to make a scarf in a couple of hours. They cost like 200-300 euros. Do you think they're a waste of money or do they actually work well? Maybe in a year I'd get tired of it anyway.
what you see on tiktok is often pure marketing, and maybe the video was made by the person selling the machine themselves. they don't work badly, though - if you already have a serious passion for knitting, they could make sense. but that's not really the point here: those machines are completely different from what you're doing now. yes, they cut down the time, but they produce more uniform and less personalized pieces, and honestly for certain projects they lose that handmade charm. if you get tired of it in a year it's probably because hand knitting is a relaxing activity, almost meditative - a machine takes away exactly that aspect.
space and money aside (those are real issues, agreed), the real deciding factor is: are you genuinely passionate about it or is it something you do when you have time? because if it's the latter, then even a machine won't change things. you'll keep knitting whenever it happens, and the machine will sit in a drawer. if instead you're already knitting quite a lot and the only limit is the time it takes, then it could work - but i'd first get higher quality machinery (not the tiktok ones) or maybe look for something reliable secondhand, without throwing 250-300 euros at an experiment right away.
The real question is: how much time do you actually spend knitting right now? Because if it's a hobby you do occasionally, a machine like that risks just sitting in a corner after two weeks. The people who actually use them are the ones who were already knitting a lot and are looking to speed things up, not people just starting out. Maybe try asking in a knitting group if anyone has one and can show you how it actually works in practice, because TikTok videos sell the dream but the results aren't always what they seem.
It all depends on how much space you have at home and whether you're really sure you'll use it. Those machines take up a ton of space, and if maybe you knit a scarf every two months, it's easy for it to end up shoved in the garage or under the bed after a while. The problem isn't whether they work - yeah, they do what they promise - but whether your hobby will shift from "something I do when I feel like it" to "something I do because I spent 250 euros and I'd feel guilty not using it."
Before you drop the money, maybe try to figure out: how many hours a month do you actually spend knitting? If it's really a lot and your wrist is starting to hurt, then it makes sense. But if it's more of something you do when it relaxes you and you're not in a rush, a machine that speeds everything up could take away the whole point of doing it. Also ask in knitting communities if they've bought one - you often find people selling theirs after two months at a discount, so maybe you could start there, and if you don't like it you can resell it with less of a hit.
I had a knitting machine years ago, one of those fairly simple ones, and I have to be honest: I barely used it. The problem isn't that it doesn't work - it works just fine, and yeah, you get things done fast. But the thing is, hand knitting has its own rhythm, its own meditative quality, and when you switch to a machine the whole experience changes. It becomes more mechanical, less creative. Plus these machines have a ton of limitations: you can't easily do complicated patterns, change colors on the fly, play around with textures. If you love the process of knitting, not just the end result, the machine might bore you pretty quickly.
Then there's the practical side, which other people have already mentioned. If you're barely knitting right now - a scarf here and there, just to chill out - it doesn't make sense to invest. But if you're already someone who churns out three or four pieces a month and you've got piles of yarn sitting around, then maybe it could make sense as a complementary tool, not a replacement. The real test is this: how many weeks would you spend in front of that machine if you had nothing else to do? If the answer is "eh, maybe two," save your money.
One last thing: TikTok videos show scarves coming out looking perfect, but they don't show you the half hours you spend threading the thing, adjusting the machine, fixing knots. It's not really plug-and-play like it seems.
These machines require annoying initial setup - you have to assemble it, figure out how it works, adjust the tension - and it's not something you do once and you're done. The real question is whether the time savings actually justify it: yeah, you'll knit a scarf faster, but you lose the pleasure of hand knitting, which for a lot of people is what the hobby's about. If you knit to relax, the machine takes away exactly that. Try asking around first if anyone you know has a machine you could test out a couple of times: that way you'll figure out if it really changes things for you before you drop 250 euros on it.
I totally get you all, but honestly I think the real issue is something else: it's not so much that the machine doesn't work, it's that hand knitting and machine knitting are two completely different experiences! With the machine you're passive, you feed in the yarn and everything turns on its own - it's more like assembling than creating. If you like knitting right now because it's meditative, because you feel the texture of the yarn between your fingers, because you can take breaks whenever you want, a machine might let you down for exactly that reason.
Then there's the practical side that others have touched on: two or three weeks of hype on TikTok isn't a good indicator of what you'll be doing in six months! If you're already knitting regularly and you genuinely think a machine would give you the right boost to do more projects, okay - but if it's an impulse buy because you saw a cute video, that's money down the drain. Maybe start by trying out a friend's, or look carefully at which models actually have solid reviews from people who've been using them for years!
I've personally seen friends get one enthusiastically, but the real bottleneck isn't the time it takes to knit - it's that if you don't already have a solid routine, a 250-euro machine ends up gathering dust even faster than your passion would. The thing is: do you get tired of knitting because the repetitive process gets boring, or because you simply don't have the time? Because a machine solves the first problem, but not the second.
Before spending the money, check if the machine you see on TikTok actually has good reviews on independent sites and not just paid comments - because a lot of these gadgets have fake reviews. Then, the real issue nobody mentions: even if the machine works, once you've knocked out a couple of identical scarves fast, the creative side just disappears, and maybe that's exactly why you started knitting in the first place.
But I think the real question is whether you actually want to change your creative process instead of hand knitting - like, with a machine you get through the mechanical part quickly and then have more time for the details, the colors, the patterns. But if you really love the actual process of hand knitting (you know, while you're watching a series or during your train ride), then a machine doesn't really interest you anyway and yeah, it just ends up shoved in the back of a closet. Before you spend 200-300 euros on one, maybe try renting one from someone for a week so you can figure out if you actually like the different workflow.
Log into answer.
