8 answers

★ Best answer

The question comes down less to price and performance than to ecosystem: if you're working in software that's better optimized for CUDA (video editing, 3D, machine learning), switching to AMD will be painful, even if the hardware is more powerful. For gaming and general tasks, sure, the RTX will handle things great and come out cheaper.

If the 4070 handles your tasks just fine, there's no point in switching - it's just wasting money. But if you're hitting performance limits and you're willing to deal with possible AMD driver issues, then the 7900 XT is worth considering, especially since the price is genuinely more attractive than what Nvidia offers in the same range.

AMD drivers have actually gotten better, but that's not the main thing - it's what you're actually doing with the card. If your 4070 handles your projects without breaking a sweat, switching to the RTX just to save money isn't worth it; but if you're hitting fps or render limits, then the RTX is only worth considering if your software runs equally well on both platforms. For CUDA apps like video editing or 3D, it'll make a more noticeable difference.

Actually, you shouldn't compare cards just by price and performance separately - it's like choosing a car based only on engine power and gas costs. The main thing you need to understand: why change your 4070 in the first place if it's working fine? I know a guy who switched from a green card to a red one just because he read online that it was two-thirds cheaper. He spent about two months struggling with the fact that his main work software (something to do with video editing) just wouldn't work properly with AMD, then switched back and called it a day.

As for the 7900 GRE specifically - yeah, it's a powerful card, yeah it's cheaper, but the question is whether you actually need that performance. The 4070 is already plenty for most tasks. The CUDA ecosystem really does matter - in video editing, 3D, neural networks, and professional software, green cards often work better or faster. AMD drivers have improved over the years, that's a fact, but that's not the main issue. The main thing is you'll spend energy on switching, and then it might turn out your software just doesn't work well with AMD.

My advice: before you make the switch, write down exactly what you're lacking. If you're bottlenecked by fps in games - that's one thing, if it's render performance - that's something else entirely. And check how well AMD actually supports the specific programs you use. Maybe just selling the 4070 doesn't make sense.

An important thing that kinda got missed - check what power supply you've got. The GRE draws noticeably more than the 4070, and if your PSU is already tight for your current setup, you'll have to replace it, which basically wipes out all the savings on the card. Plus think about how critical DLSS support is for you - AMD's version is still behind, and in some games and software that can be pretty noticeable.

The problem isn't the card itself, but that you're comparing by price instead of asking yourself why you need to upgrade in the first place. I know someone who struggled for ages with switching between ecosystems - she bought AMD to save money, and then realized her main work software just runs better on NVIDIA. Ended up being pretty expensive.

If your 4070 handles your current tasks fine and you're not hitting performance limits, then the upgrade is just a way to waste money. But if you already know you're short on fps or power for specific projects, and you're willing to deal with driver tweaks (they've actually gotten better, but still not perfect), then yeah, it might make sense to look at AMD as an option.

Are you actually noticing that your 4070 isn't cutting it, or is this more of a "might come in handy" thing?

If your card handles what you're doing - don't sweat the price and specs on paper. The big thing people often miss: the software you use might be built for NVIDIA in a way that even with the same performance on AMD, everything runs slower or less stable. That goes for not just professional apps, but popular game engines too, with all their CUDA optimizations.

The RTX makes sense only if you're ready to dive into settings, potentially deal with bugs, and spend time fixing them. If you don't actually need the extra performance, saving money isn't worth the hassle.

Николай95 asker The card handles it, but I've got a 4K monitor - I want stable 100+ fps in games. Software is mostly Steam, some professional apps on the side. I can figure things out, but time is money.

The main thing is to figure out why you're even thinking about switching in the first place. If your 4070 is handling your workload fine, even a decent savings on the GRE isn't worth it - you'll spend more time on reinstalling software, dealing with potential incompatibilities, and finding workarounds than you'll actually save. But if you're hitting a performance wall, then you need to look at what you're actually doing, because for some tasks CUDA is genuinely more critical than the cost of the card.

Your answer

Log into answer.