4 answers

★ Best answer

It's not really about which one to pick, but more about what you need it for and how long you want to keep it. You get a real tree for one season if you don't want to deal with needles all over your floor through January and you like that pine scent in your apartment; go with artificial if you have storage space and plan to use it for several years in a row.

I've been getting a plastic tree for several years now - the savings from not buying one every December outweigh the cost, plus you still have to dispose of a real tree afterward, whereas with plastic you just pull it out of the closet and you're done. The only downside is there's no smell, but lighting a candle with a pine scent is easier than sweeping up fallen needles every day.

I buy a real Christmas tree almost every year - the house smells festive, and the needles don't fall off for ages if you keep it away from the radiator. The downside is obvious: it takes up quite a bit of space, then you've got to figure out where to get rid of it, and there's needle cleanup in spring. And the price is steep, especially if you want a nice one. But that feeling of a living tree in your home, you can't buy that with anything.

Plastic comes in handy if you don't want to deal with the hassle and need a tree for years to come. Spend the money once - and you're good for at least ten seasons. Takes up less space, stores compactly, zero cleanup. Though quality varies wildly: cheap artificial trees look dull and smell like plastic, expensive ones are almost indistinguishable from real ones.

So it really comes down to what matters more to you. If you want to save space and time, and you're not sentimental about it - go for plastic. If a real tree is your symbol of the holidays and you don't mind the hassle, then get a real one. As for me, I switch it up from time to time: when I can't be bothered, I put up the synthetic one; when I want that genuine festive atmosphere - you get the real deal.

Do you have space to store it in your apartment? I was torn for a long time, because buying a real tree every year is expensive and a pain to clean up after, but there's nowhere to store a plastic one in our place. In the end I decided: I get a real one, but small, put it away from the radiator, and snap off the lower branches before I take it out so there's less shedding. It holds up great until New Year's, and the smell really creates an atmosphere that no plastic can replace. If I had lots of space, maybe I'd worry more about saving money and convenience, but as it turned out, a real tree is more practical for us.

yuriy_orlov asker Thanks, that's good advice about the lower branches! Our apartment is pretty small, so I'm leaning towards getting a real tree too, a small one.

Your answer

Log into answer.