I bought a Philips coffee maker three months ago, and it stopped turning on. I have the warranty and the receipt, but when I took it to the store, they said I broke it and the warranty doesn't cover it. How do I contest this? Do I need to go to Rospotrebnadzor?
The store has no right to just refuse without an inspection - they're required to conduct an expert examination and provide written documentation proving that it's actually your fault and not a factory defect! Demand a written refusal stating the reason and ask for a copy of the inspection report if they performed one. If the store refuses to do even that or the inspection results seem unfair to you, then yeah, it makes sense to file a complaint with Rospotrebnadzor or write a formal complaint - they handle exactly these kinds of situations, and stores catch on to that pretty quick!
I had a similar situation with a microwave - I bought it, and a couple months later it stopped heating, and the service center immediately claimed I was using it wrong somehow. Turned out it was actually a factory defect, but the store didn't want to deal with it and just kept insisting it was my mistake.
Here's the thing they didn't tell you (or hid from you) - the store can't just refuse without an official diagnostic. If the device won't turn on at all and you didn't drop it or get it wet, then it's clearly not user damage. Demand a written refusal - when you ask for something in writing, sellers suddenly get serious. Ask them to run a diagnostic and put the results on paper with the store's stamp. If they refuse - that's already a breach of their obligations.
Rospotrebnadzor will help, but try filing a complaint first. Write a complaint in two copies (one for them, one for you with a received stamp), copy your receipt and warranty card, cite articles from the consumer protection law. If the store digs in - then yeah, go to Rospotrebnadzor or even consider filing a court claim. Usually by that point the store suddenly remembers about warranty repairs.
The main thing is don't let them make that accusation without a written document. Ask them in writing to refuse with an explanation of the reasons, otherwise it'll be harder to prove later in court that the store said anything at all. They have to conduct a technical inspection at their own expense and put the results on paper, not just wave their hand dismissively.
Consumer Protection Agency is yeah, a last resort, but before that it makes sense to write a complaint to the store in two copies (one for you, one for them), where you demand either warranty repair, or a replacement, or a refund. Here's the catch: if the coffee maker's been opened or there are obvious signs of physical damage (dents, burns, something spilled on it), the store can demand an independent inspection, which you'll have to pay for. So if it looks like new - go for it without hesitation.
They didn't explain anything at all - why it's supposedly your fault? That's the key thing. The thing is, the store can't just brush you off - they have to do a technical diagnosis and give you a document with the reason for the refusal. If they refuse without inspection or with some vague stuff like "you broke it," that's a violation. Demand that they inspect the device in front of you and issue a written report with specific reasons. You can ask for a copy of the inspection report - that way they won't be able to change their story later.
If you get a written refusal, then yeah, you can file a complaint with Rospotrebnadzor or the prosecutor's office. But before that, try going to the store again and demand a proper inspection - often after that kind of pressure they'll change their mind or agree to send it to service. If the coffee maker worked fine for three months and then just wouldn't turn on - that looks more like a hidden defect than misuse. The law is on your side, don't give up.
A written refusal is the first thing you need to get, and the previous answer was right about that, but I'd add: when you go back to the store, bring your phone and ask them to put their claim in writing (preferably stamped and signed on paper) with all the reasons for the refusal. Otherwise they'll argue later about who said what. If the store refuses to document the refusal in writing, that's already a red flag - a legitimate store won't be afraid of paperwork.
After that, go ahead and contact Rospotrebnadzor, but first send a written complaint to the store itself (registered mail or in person with confirmation). The law requires the store to either fix the situation or formally refuse within 10 days. If they just brush you off - that's a violation.
Here's one thing to keep in mind: if the store refuses without putting it in writing, that's actually good for you. Because then you can file a complaint with Rospotrebnadzor and take them to court, citing the fact that the store didn't conduct any expertise at all and didn't document their refusal. But if they hand you a written refusal with some explanation, they'll at least have some line of defense.
So first, ask them for an inspection report in writing that specifies the exact signs of the defect that supposedly point to user error on your part. If they refuse to provide it or give you vague answers - that's already a violation. Your coffee maker worked fine for three months, then just stopped turning on. That's a classic sign of an electrical malfunction or an internal defect, not the result of misuse. The store has to prove that with a technical expertise report, not just guesses.
Rospotrebnadzor - yeah, it makes sense to go there, but before that try sending the store a written complaint (in person or by mail with proof of delivery). Write that you're demanding warranty repair or a replacement product in accordance with consumer protection law. The store has to respond within ten days. If they refuse - then you take that response to Rospotrebnadzor or go straight to court.
Log into answer.
