Don't bother looking at tours in November or searching a week before your departure - prices skyrocket exponentially. It's better to check offers right now and book while tour operators are still fighting for clients. Also, don't chase mythical deals like "80% off" - usually that's just price markup, and the real discount is more like 10-15%.
As for destinations, cities that haven't been popular with tourists are a good deal right now: Kazan, Tver, Suzdal are getting cheaper than Moscow and St. Petersburg, and the holiday atmosphere there is just as good. Ski resorts like Elbrus or Rosa Khutor get expensive before New Year's, but if you go not for New Year's Eve itself but from January 4-5, prices drop by 30-40% depending on the package. Sochi in winter is also decent - discounts on tours there have a real chance of being actual discounts, because fewer people head there than to the mountains.
Check Yandex.Travel, Oncenter, and tour operators themselves like Coral Travel - they sometimes have great combos that include transfers, hotels, and breakfasts at a price that looks almost reasonable. Read reviews not just about the hotel but about the specific tour operator too - otherwise you risk getting a "cheap tour, but nobody picked us up at the airport."