3 answers
The brain's timing circuits can hiccup - your memory system briefly processes something as both new and familiar at the same time, which is why it feels weirdly recognizable even though nothing actually happened before. It's probably more common than you'd think because our brains are constantly making these micro-errors in how they file and retrieve info, especially when we're tired or stressed.
I've had that uncanny moment where a conversation or room felt like I'd lived it before, and it turns out there's no single agreed-upon cause - it's likely a mix of things like your brain briefly glitching when matching current sensations to old memories, or encountering similar patterns without realizing it. As for why it happens fairly often, most people experience it now and then because our brains are constantly trying to find connections and shortcuts, so occasional misfires are just part of how memory works.
Most neuroscientists lean toward a glitch in how your brain retrieves memories - something gets flagged as "already processed" before you're actually consciously aware of it, creating that phantom recognition. It probably doesn't happen that frequently in reality; we just remember the weird moments and forget the thousands of times we experience something genuinely new without that creepy overlay.
Your answer
Log into answer.