2 answers
I've watched friends go through this and honestly it gets messy fast if you don't have a clear method. The best approach is to start by thinking about who's actually important to you and your partner - not who you feel obligated to include or who might get upset. Have a conversation with your partner first about what you both want the wedding party to look like. Do you want it huge or small? Are there people you both care about equally, or is it more your thing? Get on the same page before you start telling people yes.
Once you've got that framework, think practically. Consider how involved people actually are in your life right now, not just historically. That college roommate you haven't seen in five years probably shouldn't be a groomsman unless you're still close. Also factor in whether people can actually handle the responsibilities and costs without it being a burden - some folks have tight budgets or family situations that make being in a wedding party stressful. If someone's flaky or you've had drama, that's a sign too.
The hard part is just committing and being consistent. If you pick people based on closeness and current relationships, you can explain that to anyone who doesn't make the cut. Most people understand if you're genuine about it. And honestly, some people will be hurt no matter what - that's just how it goes. But sticking to your actual logic (proximity, current relationship, their ability to participate) makes it easier to stand by your choices without guilt.
People often end up with way bigger wedding parties than they planned because they say yes to everyone who asks or feels slighted. The real trick is deciding your core group first - like, who do you actually want standing next to you on the day, not who you feel obligated to include - and then sticking with that number. Once you've got your people locked in, the awkward conversations with others become easier because you can explain you kept it small rather than making exceptions. It hurts less when it's clearly a boundary you set for everyone.
Your answer
Log into answer.