I live in an apartment building, and the management company included a charge for solid waste disposal on my utility bill, but the garbage chute has been broken for six months and doesn't work. We sort our waste and take it out ourselves. Is it legal for them to demand payment for a service that isn't being provided? Can I refuse to pay that line item?
I had a similar situation with water supply - a pipe was leaking in the basement for several months, and the management company demanded I pay for the full volume. I started by gathering documents: receipts from bills, photos of the damage, correspondence with the management company. The key thing is to have proof that the service really isn't being provided. Without it, any claims will just sound like empty talk.
Formally, the management company has no right to charge for services not rendered - that's a violation of consumer protection law. But in practice they often rely on inertia: if someone pays without complaint, why would they change anything? Write a complaint to the management company in writing (preferably with a delivery confirmation or registered mail) demanding they remove or recalculate the line item for waste removal. Specify the exact dates of the breakdown and attach photos. Usually one letter like that is enough to get them to wake up. If it doesn't help, you can file a complaint with the housing inspection authority or the prosecutor's office - they specifically handle these kinds of situations.
As for the debt: if the management company has already issued payments, don't rush to dispute them in court. First try the peaceful route - a written complaint usually works better. Document everything you send and keep their responses. That way you'll have your bases covered if it comes to a hearing.
A certificate of non-performance of services is what you need to draw up first and foremost. This is a document that will establish the fact that the garbage chute isn't working and the service isn't being provided. Invite a representative from the management company, describe the condition of the equipment, document the date of the breakdown and the time periods during which it hasn't been repaired. This certificate will come in handy later if the dispute escalates.
Based on this certificate, you can send the management company a claim demanding a recalculation of the solid waste removal payment proportionally for the period when the service wasn't provided. The law doesn't allow charging for work that isn't being done. In fact, they're demanding payment for a service that simply doesn't exist, and that's a violation. Refusing to pay altogether is risky - they could register it as a debt - but a recalculated payment that accounts for the months the garbage chute wasn't working is a completely fair demand.
If the management company ignores the claim, you can file a complaint with your regional housing and utilities authority or housing inspectorate - that's exactly what they handle. You can also lodge a complaint with Rospotrebnadzor if it's a sanitation issue. Keep all documents and correspondence; that's your protection.
According to the law, the management company must provide the service in full or reduce the payment proportionally - that's a consumer's right. You'll definitely need an act, but I'd also advise writing a written complaint to the management company (by registered mail or through your personal account if available) asking them to either repair the garbage chute within a reasonable timeframe or recalculate your payment. If the management company ignores your complaint, you'll have documented proof of their inaction for filing a complaint with the housing inspection authority.
Pro tip: ask for a statement from the management company's account showing charges for this service over the last six months - if they're billing you for a non-existent service, this will seriously strengthen your position with the regulatory authorities, because it looks like systematic fraud rather than a mistake.
The main thing is to document the fact that the service isn't working, and then you'll have grounds not to pay. But keep in mind that the management company might argue that the garbage chute is common property, and they're supposedly responsible for its repair, not for waste removal itself. So along with the act refusing the service, demand a document from them stating when the garbage chute will be repaired - this will force them to choose: either fix it urgently or officially admit that the service isn't being provided and lower the payment.
You have the right not to pay for a service you're not receiving - that's a basic consumer rule, but management companies rarely voluntarily agree to lower payments. The key thing is not just to stop paying in silence: that can lead to fines and debt. You need to document everything and officially demand a recalculation.
Write a complaint to the management company in two copies - send one by registered mail and bring the other in person, asking for a receipt. Include exact dates when the garbage chute broke, attach photos of the broken hatch, describe how you're disposing of trash on your own. The main thing - demand either full repairs by a specific date, or a payment reduction proportional to the period the service wasn't working. You can specify what percentage you're reducing the amount of garbage you give to the management company (by your logic - 100%, if you're not using it at all).
If the management company ignores you or refuses, you can file a complaint with the supervisory management organization (if one exists in your region) or the housing inspection. At the same time, collect any documents you can: statements from neighbors, video of the broken chute, correspondence with the management company. By the way, my building had a similar situation with the heating system - it "worked" according to the meters, but half the winter our apartments were around 15 degrees. As soon as we filed an official complaint with an overpayment calculation, the management company started looking into it way faster 😅
Don't just refuse to pay, or the management company may start a collection process and damage your credit history. Instead, keep paying but at the same time submit a written complaint to the management company demanding either that they repair the trash chute or reduce your payment for that service proportionally to the time it's been out of service.
Attach copies of your payment receipts, photos of the broken equipment, and if possible describe how you're handling waste disposal yourself. If the management company ignores your complaint within a month, you can contact your regional housing inspectorate - they're required to verify whether the service is actually not being provided. After the inspection, you'll have an official document that you can use to demand compensation through court or simply have the amount deducted from your bill.
Documents are definitely necessary, but the most important thing is to formally reject the charges properly! I dealt with a similar situation in my building where heating didn't work in the stairwell for about two months. The management company wasn't going to reduce payments just like that, until I sent them a written refusal to pay that specific line item with the reason stated. Then suddenly they found the money for repairs!
Here's your action plan: first, draw up an act documenting the broken equipment together with your neighbors (preferably as a group), second, send the management company a written claim (by registered mail or through your personal account if available) stating the specific period when the service wasn't provided, and demand either restoration of the waste chute or a reduction in payment by the corresponding amount. At the same time, start gathering evidence - photos of the broken hatch, messages in the building's chat, any written confirmations from the management company acknowledging they know about the problem.
After that you can confidently pay everything else, but refuse to pay for waste disposal! The key thing is not to pay silently and not hope they'll figure something out on their own. The folks who commented earlier are right: without documents the management company will insist it's their property and they're supposedly working on repairs. But when they face a real threat of going to court, they move much faster!
Here's the thing: even if you file a report and submit a complaint, the management company can simply ignore it for months while charges keep piling up - then they'll demand the full amount at once with late fees and threats of court proceedings. Better to keep paying, but at the same time send a complaint in two copies (one with a receipt stamp), and if the management company doesn't respond or doesn't reduce the payment within 30 days, then take your documents to the housing authority or to court - that'll carry more weight. In court you can easily prove the service wasn't provided, but the process can drag on, so it's important to document everything in writing from the start.
The thing is, a management company can't just charge you for a service that isn't being provided - that's a violation of your rights as a consumer. According to the housing code, the management company is obligated to either provide the service in full or reduce the payment proportionally to the extent it's missing. Six months is unacceptable, and you're right to demand fairness.
The key here is not just to refuse payment, but to properly document the problem. Draw up an inspection report of the garbage chute together with your neighbors (at least two or three of you), write a complaint to the management company in duplicate requesting either that they fix the equipment within a set timeframe or recalculate your bill. Send it by registered mail with a delivery confirmation - this creates a legal paper trail. The management company has to respond within 30 days. If they refuse, you can skip paying that line item and file a complaint with the housing authority or go to court - with documentation in hand, you'll be in the right.
Keep in mind: some management companies try to pull the argument that you should pay for the attempt at a service, not the result. That's BS. Pay only for what you actually get. And while the dispute is going on, save all your bills and correspondence - that's your safety net.
A garbage chute is common property of the building, and its maintenance is included in the management company's services. If it's not working, the management company is obligated to either repair it or reduce the waste removal fee. The key is to document the non-working condition officially and figure out where the repair situation is stuck.
Write a formal complaint to the management company in two copies - keep one with a received stamp for your records. Describe that the service has not been provided since a specific date, and state that you require either immediate repair with a timeline or a fee reduction proportional to the period without service. At the same time, collect signatures from neighbors - a collective complaint carries more weight. If your building has a solid waste management meter (a calculation method), note that you're paying for a service you're not receiving.
Here's a practical step: ask the management company in writing whether they plan to repair the garbage chute at all and when. If the repair keeps getting postponed for months, that's grounds for a complaint to the housing inspection authority or Rospotrebnadzor about inadequate maintenance of common property. Often a single such request to the inspectorate gets the management company moving much faster than complaints alone. In advance, take photos of the garbage chute and document how you're disposing of waste on your own - this proves the service really isn't being provided.
Log into answer.
