Why don't compostable packaging actually break down?

RE reveur_lucas CA 🔍 Enthusiast 👁 77 ⚑ Report Ecology

I regularly buy products with packaging that's supposed to be compostable, like coffee bags or fruit containers. But when I put them in my home compost, they stay intact after months. Is that normal or am I doing something wrong? And honestly, I don't get why they say "compostable" if you have to send them to a specialized facility for them to actually break down.

2 answers

★ Best answer

That's totally normal - "compostable" packaging needs really high temperatures (around 58°C) and precise humidity to break down, conditions your home compost rarely reaches. The thing is, the compostable label just means "can decompose under controlled industrial conditions," not that it'll disappear in your balcony bin in a few months, which is where the confusion comes from.

Did you actually ask your region's composting service whether you can really throw them in there, or are you just assuming it's fine because it says so on the package?

The thing nobody tells you straight up is that "compostable" and "biodegradable" are totally different. A compostable package will theoretically break down into compost in industrial facilities under ultra-controlled conditions - stable temperature at minimum 58°C, precise moisture levels, regular aeration, the whole deal. Your home compost? It never does that. You're at 20-30°C tops, humidity changes with the weather, and if you're not constantly aerating it becomes anaerobic. So yeah, your bags stay intact. It's not that you're doing it wrong, it's just that these packages literally aren't designed for your situation.

What's actually weird though is the marketing. They slap "compostable" in big letters on the package knowing full well that 99% of people are gonna throw it in their home compost or at best in the trash. The infrastructure doesn't really exist to collect and process this stuff at scale. So you end up with waste that *feels* "eco-friendly" on paper but pollutes just like any other standard plastic. Honestly, before you buy this kind of product, check if there's a specialized recycling center near you, otherwise it's just greenwashing.

Your answer

Log into answer.