12 answers

★ Best answer

The main thing I'd point out is not to lose yourself in the sheer volume. Marvel puts out so many variants that you can easily fall into the "I'll just grab everything" trap, and then you realize you've got 200 comics at home, half of which you haven't even read, and they're taking up half your shelf. A collection only makes sense if you have a clear criteria: like, you're collecting variants by a specific artist, or only covers of a particular character, or only print runs below a certain number. Otherwise it's just hoarding.

The second thing people often overlook is the secondary market pricing. A variant can be expensive at release, but six months later the price could crash or skyrocket. If you're not ready to chase trends and react fast, you risk overpaying or missing out on a good deal. Plus with shipping costs from overseas (if that's where you're ordering from), the total can shift pretty dramatically.

But if the process itself matters to you more than investment returns, then yeah - go ahead and collect. People collect not to make money, but because they enjoy looking at their shelf and remembering the story behind each find. The key is knowing how much you're willing to spend per month and sticking to that.

If you're into it and ready to spend some money, then why not - collecting can be an interesting hobby. But keep in mind that it can get pretty expensive, especially if you're after rare variants, and you won't always be able to resell them without taking a loss. It only makes sense if it actually brings you pleasure, not just as an investment.

Have you actually held rare covers in your hands, or is this just an idea that caught your interest?

There's a point to collecting if you enjoy the hunt itself - searching for variants and connecting with the collector community. It's a hobby that brings joy through the search, discussing your finds, and organizing your collection. But if you're counting on it to eventually make you money - that's an illusion! Even rare variant covers don't always go up in value, and selling them later can be way harder than buying them.

Start small if you're serious about collecting. Pick, say, one artist or a comic series you really like, and collect their variant covers. That'll be cheaper and way more fun than trying to grab everything. The key thing is don't let it turn into uncontrolled spending, because Marvel keeps pumping out new variants constantly, and there's no way to chase them all!

AntonOrlov asker No, I've only been looking online so far. I'm thinking of starting with one artist, like you suggested - I really like this one guy's style.

I once tried collecting alternative covers, but I noticed that half the fun went into hunting them down online and negotiating with sellers, and then the comics just sat in a box. It only makes sense if you're willing to put them on a shelf now and then or get involved in collector forums - otherwise it's just an investment in cardboard boxes.

Thematic collections organized by artists instead of endless collecting everything - that's what saves you from clutter and overspending. Pick two or three cover artists whose work you actually love, and hunt for their pieces specifically rather than grabbing every Marvel issue. That way your collection stays compact and meaningful, and you won't end up with two hundred comics where half are just taking up shelf space.

Don't just jump into collecting everything that's an alternate cover just because it exists. It's a trap a lot of people fall into - you grab variants mechanically because they're there, then they sit at home gathering dust. A collection only makes sense if you have a clear criterion: like, all covers by a specific artist, one variant per issue in a series, or covers tied to a particular Marvel event. Without focus it's just hoarding.

Look, in my opinion the main thing is to start small and figure out if it actually brings you real enjoyment. Not just the thought of "wow, rare cover," but the actual feeling of holding the comic in your hands, studying the details. If you're buying something that ends up sitting in a box - that's not a hobby, that's just consumer behavior. I'm with what someone already said about the process: yeah, the hunt can be interesting, but if it becomes your main entertainment instead of the actual comics themselves, maybe reconsider.

And be realistic about money too. Rare covers can get pricey, and the market for this stuff is unpredictable - prices can tank if they do a reprint or a new edition comes out. Collect what you actually like aesthetically and thematically, not because you think it's an investment.

The thing is, collecting isn't about quantity - it's about what you're going to do with it next. I used to get really into beautiful fabrics and yarn for crafts, buying stuff just because I liked it. Half a year later, I realized: either I was going to use them and make something, or they'd just collect dust on a shelf, making me feel guilty. A collection of covers is pretty much the same thing. If you're just buying to say "I have the complete set," eventually it stops bringing you joy.

It's different if you're being selective - like, say, a whole series by one artist or covers of a specific character you love. Then the collection makes sense and has structure; it doesn't become a shapeless pile. And you need to be honest with yourself: are you ready to spend the money and the space in your home? Are you going to display them so you can actually see them, or store them in boxes? Because a beautiful cover deserves to be seen, not hoarded away in cardboard boxes.

The question of "should I" isn't quite right here, because the answer totally depends on what you're looking for in a hobby. Collecting only makes sense if the process itself gets you excited - not just having the stuff, but actually the hunt, studying the variants, building the logic of your collection. If your goal is just "having a nice shelf with comics," that only works for like the first couple of months.

But there's one thing you should think about ahead of time: Marvel constantly reprints old issues with new covers, so the idea of "collecting ALL variants of one issue" can turn into an endless process. Better to pick a narrow focus right away - like covers by specific artists or a series from a particular period - so your collection has actual boundaries and purpose, instead of just growing without limits.

One more practical thing: think ahead about how you're going to store and display them. If they're just boxes crammed tight in a cabinet, the joy of having them wears off pretty fast. Maybe it makes sense to put a few "star" copies on a shelf, and only collect the rest if they actually speak to you, not on the "maybe it'll get expensive later" principle.

Don't just buy everything because it looks cool - that's a straight road to a box of comics you'll never open. I had the same thing happen with plants: started collecting rare varieties, then realized I was spending half my time searching online for them while they just sat around dying on my shelves. A collection only makes sense if you're actually willing to put work into it and money's not an issue - pick a few series or artists you genuinely like, and collect the variants for those specifically, instead of chasing every single issue that comes out.

First, figure out whether you're collecting for the actual enjoyment of the comics themselves or for the hunt for rarities - those are two different things. I had a similar situation with bike parts: I bought a bunch of cool custom pieces, and then realized I was just hoarding them without actually using them. Now I only get stuff I'll regularly take out and look at, otherwise it's just money sitting in a box under the bed. If alternative covers actually appeal to you aesthetically - pick selectively instead of clearing out the entire catalog at once.

Don't just throw everything together and don't start by buying up variants just because they exist. That's the most common mistake - you grab three or four covers of the same issue, think "oh, this one's prettier," then get home and find half of them just sitting there unused, and you've spent money on a stuffed shelf instead of an actual curated collection. Better to figure out first what actually appeals to you: specific characters, certain artists, rare first-edition variants, or maybe just beautiful cover designs?

Here's a practical tip - set yourself a rule of one purchase every week or two, and before you hit that buy button, save screenshots of potential options to a special folder on your phone. Come back a week later and look through them - half of them won't seem that cool anymore. That cuts down impulse purchases by at least half.

And most importantly - comics are meant to be read, not just looked at sitting in a box. If you're collecting covers that actually make you happy, you'll actually pull them out sometimes and flip through them. But if it's just an investment or trying to hunt down something rare, you'll get bored quick, and your money will just be sitting there tied up in paper.

I tried collecting a couple years ago, and here's what I noticed: alternative covers only make sense if you're actually picking ones you like, instead of chasing completeness. I had this phase where I was buying everything just because they were rare issues, and then I realized I hadn't even taken half of them out of the box. It's way better to focus on covers from specific artists or series that actually grab you - that way your collection stays something you enjoy instead of becoming a burden.

Your answer

Log into answer.