I'm looking to replace my old 2019 Samsung TV that finally died. I keep seeing ads for smart TVs with all the streaming apps built in, but I'm wondering if it's worth the extra cost or if I should just get a basic TV and use a Roku stick like before. What's the actual difference in the long run?
Both sides here make solid points, but here's what I'd lean toward: grab a mid-range smart TV and keep a Roku stick anyway as a backup. Your TV's built-in system will get maybe 3-4 years of solid updates before the manufacturer ghosts it, but by then the Roku - which you can swap out for $30-50 - will handle the newer apps. The real hack nobody mentions is that you can disable the TV's smart features entirely and just use external hardware if the built-in stuff starts feeling sluggish or outdated, so you're not locked into whatever the manufacturer decided to stop supporting. You get the clean setup now without the commitment headache later.
A smart TV makes sense if you want something that just works out of the box without extra hardware cluttering your setup. The price difference isn't huge anymore - you're maybe paying $100-200 more for the built-in smarts, and since your TV will sit there for years, that's pretty reasonable. The real advantage is simplicity: no separate device to update, no extra remote, no cables behind the TV getting messy. If you liked using a Roku stick before and don't mind having an extra box, a basic TV plus a new streaming device works fine too, but honestly most people find the all-in-one approach less annoying once they've lived with it.
The real question is whether you trust the TV manufacturer to keep updating their OS in five years - most don't, and that's where the Roku stick wins long term. You'll get security patches and new apps on a standalone device way longer than on the TV's built-in system. If the price difference is genuinely small like the previous answer said, grab the smart TV for convenience, but don't overthink it; a basic TV plus your familiar Roku will work just fine and might actually last you longer without becoming obsolete software-wise.
How often do you actually switch between streaming services or mess with your TV's menu?
That's worth asking because it changes the calculus a bit. The earlier answers nailed the core trade-offs - manufacturer support vs. simplicity - but there's a practical middle ground most people don't think about. Smart TVs have gotten genuinely better at this stuff since 2019. The built-in systems (whether it's Samsung's Tizen, LG's WebOS, or whatever) are way more stable than they used to be, and you'll likely get 4-5 years of app updates rather than the 2-3 years of deeper support people sometimes claim. That's enough for most people's lifespan with a TV.
The real kicker though: even if the TV's smart features eventually get sluggish or stop updating, you're not stuck. You can always plug in a Roku stick later for like $30-50 without it being some emergency backup plan. It becomes more of a "nice to have" than a life raft. With a basic TV, you're already committed to needing external hardware from day one. So grab a mid-range smart TV now (and yeah, the price premium really isn't huge anymore), use it normally, and don't stress about obsolescence. If it gets wonky in five years, you'll throw a stick behind it and move on.
Log into answer.
