Skip anything labeled "hydrating" or "dewy" if you've got oily skin - those formulas are designed to add moisture, which is the opposite of what you need. Similarly, avoid heavy cream-based tints; they'll sit on your skin like a film and slide around as your natural oils come through. You want something with a lightweight, almost gel-like texture that has some oil-control ingredients built in.
Look for formulas with silicones, niacinamide, or clay components - these actually help absorb excess sebum instead of just sitting on top of it. Gel-cream hybrids tend to work better than traditional moisturizers for this, since they're designed to be less occlusive. Some people swear by mixing a tiny bit of mattifying primer under their tinted moisturizer to create a more stable base, which can help with the sliding-off problem you mentioned. You might also want to set it with a light powder on your T-zone once it's settled - not all over, just where you get shiny.
The real trick is testing things on a full day, not just in the morning. A lot of products feel fine for an hour then turn into a greasy mess, so don't judge it by the initial application. Since combination skin is finicky, you might find that what works varies slightly by season too.