I already had a synthetic belt that lasted quite a long time with me, but the difference is that the stitching never gave me any trouble - it was always the material itself that got worn down in the fold areas. A week is really too soon for the stitching to start coming loose, especially if you weren't even using it intensively.
The people there are right, that's a manufacturing defect. Decent quality synthetic leather holds the stitching together for at least a few months, easily. The tip of a belt takes tension every time you fasten and unfasten it, but it still shouldn't give way that quickly. What probably happened is the thread was sewn poorly at the factory or the material was already compromised in that spot.
My suggestion is to take it back to Renner with your receipt and the tag - most stores will swap it or refund it without questioning obvious defects like this one. If you still have the label, even better. And next time you buy one, before you leave the store, take a look at the stitching on the tips and the grommets, because that's where it usually fails first when it comes with questionable quality.