6 answers

★ Best answer

The bell does actually help, but it's not as reliable as a lot of people think - some cats just don't slow down with it, and the birds get used to it too. You could still give it a try, but don't expect miracles. What's often more effective is a combination approach: for one thing, you should limit her hunting times, so bring the cat inside in the mornings and at dusk (when birds are most active). For another, there are special vests or harnesses that restrict movement - not meant to be cruel, but they do reduce her jumping power.

I've also heard that some people put nets over certain areas in the garden or plant dense bushes where birds land. That basically cuts down on "hunting opportunities." And honestly, if your cat is really obsessive - some are just too successful as hunters - you have to accept that outdoor cats do hunt. That's not mean-spirited, but it's just their nature.

Keeping her inside completely probably isn't practical if she's not used to it. But a compromise might be to only let her out at certain times, or build a large outdoor enclosure if you have the space. That way you can keep her active without locking her up completely.

Here's what's really important: just keeping her indoors because it's annoying doesn't really work - your cat will be unhappy and you'll end up stressed with her. What a lot of people don't realize: you can also build an outdoor enclosure or a secured balcony area where your cat can go outside, but can't hunt - she gets sun and exercise without birds having to pay the price. The bell isn't reliable like I said, but combined with something like that you could really cut down on the hunting. How much space do you actually have available?

Matthias Schulz asker Small terrace and a small garden, maybe 20 square meters total. Unfortunately, a full aviary isn't realistic for me.

How much time do you spend outside with her, or do you just let her roam on her own? That makes a big difference. Your colleagues are right that just keeping her locked up isn't a good solution, but "bell + hope" really doesn't work reliably - some cats just completely ignore it. What actually helps much better: taking her out on a leash or harness when you have the time. Sounds like a lot of work, but at least then she's hunting under your supervision and you can distract her before she catches birds. Alternatively, there are also special nets for balconies or gardens if you have one - then she gets her freedom, but the birds are relatively safe.

Matthias Schulz asker Yeah, I have a garden. She just goes out there on her own, I'm not always outside. A leash is out of the question - she really doesn't like it.

The best solution I've found myself: keeping a cat occupied so she doesn't spend so much time hunting in the first place. For me, it helped to play actively with the cat outside regularly - with a feather toy or laser - so she can satisfy her hunting instinct without actually catching real birds. It sounds like more effort, but it works much better than just putting a bell collar on her or locking her up completely. A couple of other practical things: put bird feeders far away from the house (so the birds don't walk right past it), and also see if your cat might prefer staying indoors during the day - some cats are more active in the evenings than in the mornings and bring home less then.

A bell collar doesn't really help much - lots of cats hunt just as successfully anyway, and birds learn to deal with it pretty quickly. Way better is something called a Birdie Bib or similar collars with fringe that disrupts the jumping motion during an attack - that works a lot more reliably because it makes the physical ability to catch harder instead of just making noise. 🐱 And yeah, just keeping her indoors isn't a solution for a cat that goes outside, but you can also make compromises: for example, limit her outdoor time (mornings and evenings are when most birds are active anyway) or take her outside on a long lead and actively engage with her - then she'll hunt less out of boredom and hunting instinct.

One trick I haven't seen mentioned yet: try getting her a collar with a little plastic pouch pocket attached to it. It looks normal, but when she hunts, it makes things just a bit too heavy or awkward around her neck without being uncomfortable - just enough that she's less successful at it. Some cats just lose interest after that. You can buy them, doesn't cost much.

Otherwise: the combination of a bell AND less outdoor time works better than either one alone. If your cat is only allowed out in the mornings for two hours instead of all day, the success rate drops noticeably. It's not the same as locking her up completely - most cats are fine with it if they get their outdoor time regularly, even if it's not 24/7. Plus: the more toys and activities indoors, the less hunting drive in the first place.

Important too: make sure windows and doors are secure so she can't sneak out. And honestly, your cat only brings home what she can actually catch - if there's less prey hanging around nearby or she has fewer chances to pounce, the problem partly solves itself.

Your answer

Log into answer.