The framing here slightly misses the mark - CDs aren't really "coming back" in any meaningful way, but what IS happening is that a small segment of listeners are deliberately stepping away from algorithmic feeds for the reasons you've mentioned. The numbers are still minuscule compared to streaming, so it's more accurate to say certain people are opting out rather than a genuine reversal.
That said, there's a practical angle that matters here: CDs have become absurdly cheap on the used market because nobody wanted them for so long. You can grab entire albums for a few dollars at thrift stores, which makes it basically risk-free experimentation. Unlike streaming where you're locked into whatever's algorithmically fed to you, you can just... own something and listen to it however you want. No subscriptions, no tracking, no "because you listened to this, you might like that" nonsense. Some people find that genuinely refreshing - not because CDs are objectively better (they're not), but because the listening experience is on your terms.
The real appeal seems less about the physical object itself and more about reclaiming agency. Streaming has trained us to think of music as an infinite buffet where we graze constantly, but an album is still a finite thing with an arc. Whether that arc matters to you personally is another question, but for folks who felt lost in algorithmic soup, going back to discrete, intentional listening units feels radical by comparison.