The real difference was that TikTok's algorithm actually showed you stuff from creators you didn't follow, while Reels and Shorts initially leaned hard on content from people you already followed - which is a fundamentally different experience. I got curious about this a few years back and made a test account on each platform with zero follows, and TikTok started feeding me genuinely engaging videos within minutes, whereas the other two felt like empty rooms until I hunted down accounts myself. By the time Meta and Google built out their discovery algorithms to compete, TikTok had already normalized the idea that a short-form app's entire purpose was algorithmic serendipity, not just a feed of your friends' clips. That's a harder habit to break than people realize.