The gap between matching and that first reply says a lot about how someone uses the app. Some people genuinely only check once every few days, some are juggling multiple matches and forget, and some are keeping you on the back burner while they explore other options. None of these are necessarily red flags on their own - it's just context. The real question is whether you'd want to date someone who operates that way. If slow responses bother you now, they'll probably bother you once you're actually dating them too.
I'd keep the match open unless they go silent for over a week or their vibe feels off when they do reply. Here's a practical angle nobody mentioned: when someone does message back after days, pay attention to *what* they write. Are they just sending a lazy emoji or one-word replies? That's different from someone who sends a thoughtful message apologizing for the delay. The effort in that comeback message tells you whether they're genuinely interested or just scrolling through their old matches with nothing better to do.
Don't unmatch as a reflex, but also don't sit around waiting. The first person's advice about talking to others is solid - treat the app like a normal part of your week, not a constant thing. If you match with someone Tuesday and they reply Friday, cool. If you're still curious, engage. But if you've already moved on to someone more responsive by then, that's not a loss.